On the Use of Expert Judgments to Estimate the Pressure Increment in the Sequoyah Containment at Vessel Breach
Authors:
- 1 January 1994
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Nuclear Technology
- Vol. 105 (1) , 87-103
Abstract
The use of expert judgments in probabilistic risk assessments has become common. Simple aggregation methods have often been used with the result that expert biases and interexpert dependence are often neglected. Sophisticated theoretical models for the use of expert opinions have been proposed that offer ways of incorporating expert biases and dependence, but they have not found wide acceptance because of the difficulty and rigor of these methods. Practical guidance on the use of the versatile Bayesian expert judgment aggregation model is provided. In particular, the case study of pressure increment due to vessel breach in the Sequoyah nuclear power plant is chosen to illustrate how phenomenological uncertainty can be addressed by using the Bayesian aggregation model. The results indicate that the Bayesian aggregation model is a suitable candidate model for aggregating expert judgments, especially if there is phenomenological uncertainty. Phenomenological uncertainty can be represented through the dependence parameter of the Bayesian model. This is because the sharing of assumptions by the experts tends to introduce dependence between the experts. The extent of commonality in the experts’ beliefs can be characterized by assessing their interdependence. The results indicate that uncertainty is possibly underestimated by ignoring dependence. Two Bayesian approaches are used. The first approach uses the experts’ opinions as evidence to update the decision maker’s state of knowledge. The second approach, in recognition of the fact that the experts are highly dependent on a common information source, assumes that the common information source is the actual expert and the participants are assessing its biases and credibility. The results lend validity to the use of weighted averaging schemes because the Bayesian aggregation method encompasses simple arithmetic and geometric averaging techniques.Keywords
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- A taxonomy of issues related to the use of expert judgments in probabilistic safety studiesReliability Engineering & System Safety, 1992
- ‘Expert information’ versus ‘expert opinions’. Another approach to the problem of eliciting/ combining/using expert knowledge in PRAReliability Engineering & System Safety, 1992
- Expert Opinion in Risk Analysis: The NUREG-1150 MethodologyNuclear Science and Engineering, 1989
- Filtering information from human expertsIEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics, 1989
- The Assessment of Probability Distributions from Expert Opinions with an Application to Seismic Fragility CurvesRisk Analysis, 1986
- Limits for the Precision and Value of Information from Dependent SourcesOperations Research, 1985
- Effects of expertise and experience on risk judgments.Journal of Applied Psychology, 1983
- Data analysis in risk assessmentsNuclear Engineering and Design, 1982
- Assessment of a Prior Distribution for the Correlation Coefficient in a Bivariate Normal DistributionJournal of the Royal Statistical Society. Series A (General), 1982
- Judgment under Uncertainty: Heuristics and BiasesScience, 1974