Science, Values, and the New Demarcation Problem
Authors:
Top Cited Papers
- 22 February 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal for General Philosophy of Science
- Vol. 54 (2) , 259-286
Abstract
In recent years, many philosophers of science have rejected the “value-free ideal” for science, arguing that non-epistemic values have a legitimate role to play in scientific inquiry. However, this philosophical position raises the question of how to distinguish between legitimate and illegitimate influences of values in science. In this paper, we argue that those seeking to address this “new” demarcation problem can benefit by drawing lessons from the “old” demarcation problem, in which philosophers tried to find a way of distinguishing between science and non-science. Many of those who worked on this problem ultimately found that efforts to provide necessary and sufficient conditions for defining science failed, and most concluded that the best solution to the problem was to characterize scientific hypotheses, theories, and research programs in terms of some common norms. We suggest that those seeking to distinguish between legitimate and illegitimate value influences on science would do well to adopt a similar approach. Rather than attempting to establish necessary and sufficient conditions for identifying appropriate value influences, it will be more fruitful to evaluate scientific activities based on their adherence to a set of epistemic and ethical norms that can be implemented in scientific practice by means of rules, conventions, policies, and procedures.Keywords
Funding Information
- National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences
This publication has 89 references indexed in Scilit:
- DNA fingerprinting in forensics: past, present, futureInvestigative Genetics, 2013
- Scientific Research and the Public TrustScience and Engineering Ethics, 2010
- Cutting the Gordian Knot of DemarcationInternational Studies in the Philosophy of Science, 2009
- Why Public Health Agencies Cannot Depend on Good Laboratory Practices as a Criterion for Selecting Data: The Case of Bisphenol AEnvironmental Health Perspectives, 2009
- Uses of Value Judgments in Science: A General Argument, with Lessons from a Case Study of Feminist Research on DivorceHypatia, 2004
- Empirical Equivalence and UnderdeterminationThe Journal of Philosophy, 1991
- Health as a Theoretical ConceptPhilosophy of Science, 1977
- The Structure of ScienceAmerican Journal of Physics, 1961
- Valuation and Acceptance of Scientific HypothesesPhilosophy of Science, 1956
- The Paradox of VerifiabilityPhilosophy and Phenomenological Research, 1951