Meta-Analysis of the Effects of Early Education Interventions on Cognitive and Social Development
Authors:
Top Cited Papers
- 1 March 2010
- journal article
- review article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Teachers College Record: the Voice of Scholarship in Education
- Vol. 112 (3) , 579-620
Abstract
There is much current interest in the impact of early childhood education programs on preschoolers and, in particular, on the magnitude of cognitive and affective gains. Because this new segment of public education may require substantial resources, accurate descriptions are required of the potential benefits and costs of implementing specific preschool programs. To address this issue comprehensively, a meta-analysis was conducted for the purpose of synthesizing the outcomes of comparative studies in this area. A total of 123 comparative studies of early childhood interventions were analyzed. Each study provided a number of contrasts, where a contrast is defined as the comparison of an intervention group of children with an alternative intervention or no intervention group. A prevalent pedagogical approach in these studies was direct instruction, but inquiry-based pedagogical approaches also occurred in some interventions. No assumption was made that nominally similar interventions were equivalent. The meta-analytic database included both quasi-experimental and randomized studies. A coding strategy was developed to record information for computing study effects, study design, sample characteristics, and program characteristics. Consistent with the accrued research base on the effects of preschool education, significant effects were found in this study for children who attend a preschool program prior to entering kindergarten. Although the largest effect sizes were observed for cognitive outcomes, a preschool education was also found to impact children's social skills and school progress. Specific aspects of the treatments that positively correlated with gains included teacher-directed instruction and small-group instruction, but provision of additional services tended to be associated with negative gains. Given the current state of research on the efficacy of early childhood interventions, there is both good and bad news. The good news is that a host of original and synthetic studies have found positive effects for a range of outcomes, and this pattern is clearest for outcomes relating to cognitive development. Moreover, many promising variables for program design have been identified and linked to outcomes, though little more can be said of the link than that it is positive. The bad news is that there is much less empirical information in the studies examined available for designing interventions at multiple levels with multiple components.Keywords
This publication has 48 references indexed in Scilit:
- A Potential for Bias When Rounding in Multiple ImputationThe American Statistician, 2003
- Differential effects of three preschool models on inner-city 4-year-oldsEarly Childhood Research Quarterly, 1992
- A Longitudinal Study of Two Early Intervention Strategies: Project CAREChild Development, 1990
- Are Head Start Effects Sustained? A Longitudinal Follow-Up Comparison of Disadvantaged Children Attending Head Start, No Preschool, and Other Preschool ProgramsChild Development, 1990
- Type of Day-Care and Preschool Intellectual Development in Disadvantaged ChildrenChild Development, 1989
- Intervention Strategies for Spanish-Speaking Preschool ChildrenChild Development, 1971
- The Use of a Structured Curriculum with Black Preschool Disadvantaged ChildrenThe Journal of Negro Education, 1971
- Performance of Head Start and Non-Head Start Participants at First GradeThe Journal of Negro Education, 1970
- Psychometric Evaluation of an Operation Headstart ProgramThe Journal of Genetic Psychology, 1967
- Effectiveness of parents of Head Start children as administrators of psychological tests.Journal of Consulting Psychology, 1967