Comparison and Evaluation of Open-Source Panel Method Codes against Commercial Codes
- 30 June 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by TMMOB Gemi Muhendisleri Odasi in Gemi ve Deniz Teknolojisi
- No. 221,p. 86-108
Abstract
This work provides a benchmark study regarding the open-source panel method codes of two floating wind turbine platforms. HAMS, NEMOH, and WAMIT are compared in terms of their results, computational performance, user-friendliness, and, flexibility. WAMIT’s data is sourced from previous publications for the OC3 Hywind Spar and OC4 DeepCWind Semisubmersible. These reference values are compared to NEMOH and HAMS for the main parameters representing the movement of the structure: wave excitation forces, added mass values, and potential damping. Both of the open source panel method codes were quite successful in the concept of a simple one-piece spar float rather than a multibody semi-submersible in terms of NRMS values. Overall, the most close results were obtained from the surge for added mass, and the most unfavorable results were from radiation damping in the heave. NEMOH brings ineligible results for pitch on both platforms. Neglecting the pitch axis results of NEMOH, both codes showed parallel and reasonably close results to WAMIT. The study aims to help researchers to choose a free open-source alternative to a validated commercial code.Keywords
This publication has 35 references indexed in Scilit:
- The effects of wind-induced inclination on the dynamics of semi-submersible floating wind turbines in the time domainRenewable Energy, 2016
- Finite order approximations to radiation forces for wave energy applications2015
- Potential time domain model with viscous correction and CFD analysis of a generic surging floating wave energy converterInternational Journal of Marine Energy, 2015
- Influence of Model Simplifications Excitation Force in Surge for a Floating Foundation for Offshore Wind TurbinesEnergies, 2015
- The Environment and Environmental Load of Offshore Oil Engineering2014
- Motion of OC4 5MW Semi-Submersible Offshore Wind Turbine in Irregular Waves2013
- Offshore environmental loads and wind turbine design: impact of wind, wave, currents and ice2011
- Floating Offshore Wind Turbines: Responses in a Seastate Pareto Optimal Designs and Economic Assessment2008
- Feasibility Study of Floating Windfarms in Shallow Offshore SitesWind Engineering, 2003
- The Force Exerted by Surface Waves on PilesJournal of Petroleum Technology, 1950