Numerical Study of Soil–Nail Structural Elements Performance Using Different Soil Constitutive Models
Open Access
- 1 January 2025
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Advances in Civil Engineering
- Vol. 2025 (1)
Abstract
Contemporary geotechnical engineering practice increasingly employs soil nailing technology for slope stabilization and excavation support. This necessitates comprehensive evaluation of not only stability but also wall displacements and nail performance to ensure structural integrity. This study investigates soil–nail system performance through finite element analysis comparing three constitutive models (Mohr‐Coulomb [MC], hardening soil [HS], Hardening Soil Model with Small‐Strain Stiffness [HSS]) and three structural elements (embedded beams [EBs], plates, and geogrids). Initial simulations replicate field conditions using MC model‐embedded beam (EB) element combinations, followed by comparative HS/HSS analyses and evaluation of plates/geogrids element effects. The numerical results demonstrate significant variations in displacement and axial force predictions across different constitutive models. The MC model yields the highest displacement values among all tested formulations, followed by the HS and HSS models. When employing EB elements, the displacement discrepancies relative to observed field data ( d = 0) are 0.13% (0.01 mm) for MC, 32.32% (2.94 mm) for HS, and 72.01% (6.55 mm) for HSS. Correspondingly, axial force analysis reveals the MC model produces 1.53% (0.11 kN) higher tensile forces than measured values, while the HS and HSS models show 10.39% (0.73 kN) and 16.12% (1.13 kN) reductions, respectively. Displacement analysis across structural elements shows EBs produce the highest deformations (0.13%; 0.01 mm deviation from field data), followed by plates (28.04%; 2.55 mm) and geogrids (28.69%; 2.61 mm). Axial force comparisons reveal more pronounced differences, while EBs show minimal deviation (+ 1.53%; 0.11 kN), plates and geogrids exhibit substantial reductions (−92.49%; −6.47 kN and −79.96%; −5.60 kN, respectively) relative to observations. This indicate plates generate significantly higher tensile stresses than geogrids or EBs.Keywords
This publication has 12 references indexed in Scilit:
- GEP-based empirical models for estimation of soil nail bond strength in weathered soilKSCE Journal of Civil Engineering, 2025
- Numerical investigation of gravity-grouted soil-nail pullout capacity in sandOpen Geosciences, 2023
- FEM Analysis of Soil Nails Performance in Excavation of Different Soil TypesInternational Journal of Research in Advent Technology, 2019
- 2D Numerical Simulations of Soil Nail WallsGeotechnical and Geological Engineering, 2009
- Numerical study on the optimum layout of soil–nailed slopesComputers and Geotechnics, 2008
- Soil-Nailed Wall Under Piled Bridge Abutment: Simulation and GuidelinesJournal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering, 1997
- Finite element modelling of the construction of a full-scale expexperimental soil-nailed wall. French National Research Project CLOUTERREProceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers - Ground Improvement, 1997
- Numerical Analysis of a Full Scale Experimental Soil Nailed Wall1997
- A finite element study of the pressuremeter test in sand using a nonlinear elastic plastic modelCanadian Geotechnical Journal, 1993
- Analysis for Soil Reinforcement with Bending StiffnessJournal of Geotechnical Engineering, 1992