Accuracies of facial soft tissue depth means for estimating ground truth skin surfaces in forensic craniofacial identification
- 14 November 2014
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in International journal of legal medicine
- Vol. 129 (4) , 877-888
Abstract
Facial soft tissue thickness means have long been used as a proxy to estimate the soft tissue envelope, over the skull, in craniofacial identification. However, estimation errors of these statistics are not well understood, making casework selection of the best performing estimation models impossible and overarching method accuracies controversial. To redress this situation, residuals between predicted and ground truth values were calculated in two experiments: (1) for 27 suites of means drawn from 10 recently published studies, all examining the same 10 landmarks (N ≥ 3051), and tested against six independent raw datasets of contemporary living adults (N = 797); and (2) pairwise tests of the above six, and five other, raw datasets (N = 1063). In total, 380 out-of-sample tests of 416 arithmetic means were conducted across 11 independent samples. Experiment 1 produced an overarching mean absolute percentage error (MAE) of 29 % and a standard error of the estimate (S est) of 2.7 mm. Experiment 2 yielded MAE of 32 % and S est of 2.8 mm. In any instance, MAE was always ≥20 % of the ground truth value. The overarching 95 % limits of the error, for contemporary samples, was large (11.4 mm). CT-derived means from South Korean males and Black South African females routinely performed well across the test samples and produced the smallest errors of any tests (but did so for Black American male reference samples). Sample-specific statistics thereby performed poorly despite discipline esteem. These results—and the practice of publishing means without prior model validation—demand major reforms in the field.Keywords
This publication has 63 references indexed in Scilit:
- Influence of sex and body mass index on facial soft tissue thickness measurements of the northern Chinese adult populationForensic Science International, 2012
- Age and sex related measurement of craniofacial soft tissue thickness and nasal profile in the Chinese populationForensic Science International, 2011
- In VivoFacial Tissue Depth Study of Chinese‐American Adults in New York City*Journal of Forensic Sciences, 2011
- Facial Soft Tissue Depths in Craniofacial Identification (Part I): An Analytical Review of the Published Adult Data*Journal of Forensic Sciences, 2008
- Comparability of Radiographic and 3D‐Ultrasound Measurements of Facial Midline Tissue Depths*Journal of Forensic Sciences, 2006
- Facial Soft Tissue Thicknesses in Australian Adult Cadavers*Journal of Forensic Sciences, 2005
- Facial approximation: Comments on Stephan (2003)American Journal of Physical Anthropology, 2004
- Use of Facial Approximation Techniques in Identification of Green River Serial Murder VictimsAmerican Journal of Forensic Medicine & Pathology, 1991
- Bizygomatic diameter: The thickness of the soft tissues over the zygionsAmerican Journal of Physical Anthropology, 1969
- The location of the nasion in the livingAmerican Journal of Physical Anthropology, 1935