The Ethics and Law of Confidentiality in Criminal Justice Research: A Comparison of Canada and the United States
Authors:
- John LowmanJLJohn Lowman
- Ted PalysTPTed Palys
- 1 May 2001
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Criminal Justice Review
- Vol. 11 (1) , 1-33
Abstract
The Academy of Criminal Justice Sciences Code of Ethics and the American Society of Criminology Draft Code of Ethics raise the possibility of a conflict arising between research ethics and the law relating to evidentiary and testimonial privilege. However, they say nothing about the form that legal threats to research confidentiality may take in Canada and the United States, the two countries where these codes apply, nor do they describe the strategies that researcher can employ to protect confidential research information in court. The purpose ofthis article is to address these matters. It begins with a brief description ofthe role that confidentiality plays in protecting research participants and maintaining the validity and reliability of criminal justice research. It then describes the legal context in which the researchers' ethical obligations unfold and the strategies that researchers can employ to protect confidential research information when third parties use legal force to try to obtain it. The article argues that the ethical responsibilities of rea s studying criminal justice issues are bet fulfilled and their research participants best protected when researchers ue their understanding of law to design research so as to anticipate the evidentiary requirements of the courts. It concludes with a discussion of the respective advantages and disadvantages of statutory as compared to common law protections for research confidentiality.Keywords
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- Ethics and Institutional Conflict of Interest: The Research Confidentiality Controversy at Simon Fraser UniversitySociological Practice, 2000
- Ethical and Legal Strategies for Protecting Confidential Research InformationCanadian Journal of Law and Society / Revue Canadienne Droit et Société, 2000
- From the Field to the Courthouse: Should Social Science Research Be Privileged?Law & Social Inquiry, 1999
- Science and Subpoenas: When Do the Courts Become Instruments of Manipulation?Law and Contemporary Problems, 1996
- A Researcher's Privilege: Does Any Hope Remain?Law and Contemporary Problems, 1996
- Judicially Compelled Disclosure of Researchers' Data: A Judge's ViewLaw and Contemporary Problems, 1996
- Compelled Disclosure of Scholarly Research: Some Comments on "High Stakes Litigation"Law and Contemporary Problems, 1996
- Trial and tribulations: Courts, ethnography, and the need for an evidentiary privilege for academic researchersThe American Sociologist, 1995
- Legal Intrusion and the Politics of FieldworkUrban Life, 1986
- The Prosecutor and the Researcher: Present and Prospective Variations on the Supreme Court's Branzburg DecisionSocial Problems, 1973