Use and Understanding of Anonymization and De-Identification in the Biomedical Literature: Scoping Review
Open Access
- 31 May 2019
- journal article
- review article
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in Journal of Medical Internet Research
- Vol. 21 (5) , e13484
Abstract
Journal of Medical Internet Research - International Scientific Journal for Medical Research, Information and Communication on the Internet #Preprint #PeerReviewMe: Warning: This is a unreviewed preprint. Readers are warned that the document has not been peer-reviewed by expert/patient reviewers or an academic editor, may contain misleading claims, and is likely to undergo changes before final publication, if accepted, or may have been rejected/withdrawn. Readers with interest and expertise are encouraged to sign up as peer-reviewer, if the paper is within an open peer-review period. Please cite this preprint only for review purposes or for grant applications and CVs (if you are the author). Background: The secondary use of health data is central to biomedical research in the era of data science and precision medicine. National and international initiatives, such as the GO FAIR initiative, are supporting this approach in different ways (e.g. making the sharing of research data mandatory or improving the legal and ethical frameworks). Preserving patients’ privacy is crucial in this context. ‘De-identification’ and ‘anonymization’ are the two most common terms used to refer to the technical approaches which protect privacy and facilitate the secondary use of health data. However, it is difficult to find a consensus on the definitions of the concepts or on the reliability of the techniques used to apply them. A comprehensive review is needed to better understand the domain, its capabilities, its challenges, and the ratio of risk between the data subjects’ privacy on one side, and the benefit of scientific advances on the other. Objective: This work aims at better understanding how the research community comprehends and defines the concepts of de-identification and anonymization. A rich overview should also provide insights into the use and reliability of the methods. Six aspects will be studied: (1) terminology and definitions; (2) background and place of work of the researchers; (3) reasons for anonymizing or de-identifying health data; (4) limitations of the techniques; (5) legal and ethical aspects; (6) recommendations of the researchers. Methods: Based on a scoping review protocol designed a priori, MEDLINE was searched for publications discussing de-identification or anonymization and published between 2007 and 2017. The search was restricted to MEDLINE to focus on the life science community. The screening process was performed by two reviewers independently. Results: After searching 7972 records that matched at least one search term, 135 publications were screened, and 60 full-text articles were included. (1) Terminology: Definitions of the terms ‘de-identification’ and ‘anonymization’ were provided in less than half of the articles (n=29, 48%). When both terms were used (n=41, 68%), their meanings divided the authors into two equal groups (n=19, 32%) with opposed views. The remaining articles (n=3, 5%) were equivocal. (2) Background and location: Research groups were based predominantly in North America (n=31, 52%) and in the European Union (n=22, 36.7%). The authors came from 19 different domains. Computer Science (36.7%), Biomedical Informatics (19%), and Medicine (15.3%) were the most prevalent ones. (3) Purpose: The main reason declared for applying these techniques is to facilitate biomedical research. (4) Limitations: Progress is made on specific techniques, but overall, limitations remain numerous. (5) Legal and Ethics: Differences exist between nations in the definitions, approaches, and legal practices (6) Recommendations: The combination of organizational, legal, ethical, and technical approaches is necessary to protect health data. Conclusions: Interest is growing for privacy-enhancing techniques in the life sciences community. This interest crosses scientific boundaries, involving primarily Computer Science, Biomedical Informatics, and Medicine. The variability observed in the use of the terms ‘de-identification’ and ‘anonymization’ emphasizes the need for clearer definitions as well as for better education and dissemination of information on the subject. The same observation applies to the methods. Several legislations such as the American Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) and the European General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) regulate the domain. Using the definitions they provide could help address the variable use of these two concepts in the research community.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 67 references indexed in Scilit:
- Development and evaluation of a de-identification procedure for a case register sourced from mental health electronic recordsBMC Medical Informatics and Decision Making, 2013
- Strategies for De-identification and Anonymization of Electronic Health Record Data for Use in Multicenter Research StudiesMedical Care, 2012
- Secondary uses and the governance of de-identified data: Lessons from the human genome diversity panelBMC Medical Ethics, 2011
- Never too old for anonymity: a statistical standard for demographic data sharing via the HIPAA Privacy RuleJournal of the American Medical Informatics Association, 2011
- Scoping studies: advancing the methodologyImplementation Science, 2010
- Automatic de-identification of textual documents in the electronic health record: a review of recent researchBMC Medical Research Methodology, 2010
- Anonymization of electronic medical records for validating genome-wide association studiesProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2010
- Preparing raw clinical data for publication: guidance for journal editors, authors, and peer reviewersTrials, 2010
- A Model for Expanded Public Health Reporting in the Context of HIPAAJournal of the American Medical Informatics Association, 2008
- Toward a National Framework for the Secondary Use of Health Data: An American Medical Informatics Association White PaperJournal of the American Medical Informatics Association, 2007