Wittfogel's dilemma: heterarchy and ethnographic approaches to irrigation management in Eastern Africa and Mesopotamia
- 21 February 2009
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in World Archaeology
- Vol. 41 (1) , 16-35
Abstract
Both ethnographic and archaeological studies have been used to critique Wittfogel's hydraulic theory. These, however, often present data that are contradictory and in need of reformulation. In particular, while ethnographic studies emphasize the management of irrigation in the absence of both socio-political hierarchies and marked social stratification, archaeologists continue to see irrigation agriculture as a key influence on the development of personal accumulation and increased social stratification. Through two East African ethnographic case studies, this paper addresses the mechanisms through which irrigation agriculture might contribute to increased social stratification and cautions against the making of simplistic assumptions. I argue that both ethnographic and archaeological lines of critique have resulted in a hasty rejection of the role played by irrigation management in the formation of loci of authority in early complex societies.Keywords
This publication has 36 references indexed in Scilit:
- Pathways to complexity: an African perspective1999
- Modeling political organization in large-scale settlement clusters: a case study from the Inland Niger Delta1999
- Water scarcity, property regimes and irrigation management in Sonjo, TanzaniaThe Journal of Development Studies, 1998
- Irrigation and the Rise of the State in Hunza: A Case for the Hydraulic HypothesisModern Asian Studies, 1997
- The Harsh Facts of Hydraulics: Technology and Society in Sri Lanka's Colonization SchemesTechnology and Culture, 1990
- Social and Political Aspects of Intensive Agriculture in East Africa: Some Models from Cultural AnthropologyAzania: Archaeological Research in Africa, 1989
- Canal Irrigation and Local Social Organization [and Comments and Reply]Current Anthropology, 1976
- The Hydraulic Hypothesis: A ReappraisalCurrent Anthropology, 1973
- The wet and the dry: Traditional irrigation in Bali and MoroccoHuman Ecology, 1972
- Investigating the Origins of Mesopotamian CivilizationScience, 1966