Abstract
In some sense, the question about the quality of an argument is the ‘ultimate’ one for argument mining. Being able to reconstruct argumentative structures from a text (Chaps. 4 – 5 ) and learning about the perspectives that arguments convey toward a topic (Chap. 6 ) lays the ground to make arguments processable by machines. However, nearly all practical applications of NLP research on argumentation require some distinction of good from bad arguments, in order to focus on the strongest arguments or to identify weak arguments. Argument search engines aim to rank the best arguments highest, debating technologies aim to choose arguments that help convince their opponent or audience, argumentative writing assistance tools aim to spot the weak points to give feedback on, and so forth. In this chapter, we therefore discuss how to assess argument quality with computational means.