Comparison of Three Quality Assurance Methods for Clinical Ultrasound Devices
Authors:
Open Access
- 10 February 2025
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Medical and Biological Engineering
- Vol. 45 (1) , 147-155
Abstract
Purpose: The purpose of the work was to compare the performance of different ultrasound quality assurance methods in finding transducer defects. For this, three different commonly used ultrasound QA methods were studied and compared. Methods: The integrity of 99 US transducers was measured using the FirstCall transducer test in two tertiary healthcare centers in Finland. Thereafter, the ability of three different quality assurance methods (the FirstCall sensitivity test, in-air reverberation test, and uniformity test) to find defective probes was evaluated with a sub-group (N=37) of probes. All sensors were classified as either defective or functional according to predefined criteria. Results: According to the 99 FirstCall measurement reports, 31% of the transducers were defective. The sensitivity test, in-air test, and uniformity test identified 27, 27, and 14% of the transducers, respectively, as defective. The agreement between the three quality assurance methods was 78%. Conclusion: Even if ultrasound quality assurance is performed systematically, the number of undetected defective transducers can still be high. FirstCall allows the transducers to be measured independently and is useful in testing the sensitivity and capacitance of each element and the wiring. The in-air reverberation test is effective in finding transducer failures. It is the easiest and fastest to implement and is therefore recommended to be performed regularly for all ultrasound transducers in clinical use along with the mechanical inspection. The uniformity test requires a phantom and can be used to confirm a possible defect found by the two other methods.Keywords
Funding Information
- Tampere University Hospital, Wellbeing Services County of Pirkanmaa (9AA003)
- Tampere University
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- An adaptation of the ultrasound transducer element test for multi-row arraysPhysica Medica, 2021
- Ultrasound Probe Acceptance Testing Using the In-Air Reverberation PatternUltrasound in Medicine & Biology, 2019
- Evaluations of UltraiQ software for objective ultrasound image quality assessment using images from a commercial scannerJournal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics, 2018
- Blinded Comparison between an In-Air Reverberation Method and an Electronic Probe Tester in the Detection of Ultrasound Probe FaultsUltrasound in Medicine & Biology, 2017
- A review of the recommendations governing quality assurance of ultrasound systems used for guidance in prostate brachytherapyPhysica Medica, 2017
- Routine Ultrasound Quality Assurance in a Multi-Unit Radiology Department: A Retrospective Evaluation of Transducer FailuresUltrasound in Medicine & Biology, 2017
- A simple uniformity test for ultrasound phased arraysPhysica Medica, 2016
- Quality assurance in diagnostic ultrasoundEuropean Journal of Radiology, 2011
- Four-Year Experience with a Clinical Ultrasound Quality Control ProgramUltrasound in Medicine & Biology, 2011
- Estimation of Average Speed of Sound Using Deconvolution of Medical Ultrasound DataUltrasound in Medicine & Biology, 2010