Heinz Kohut’s emphasis on empathy and mutuality emerged organically from his spiritual commitments. He was not traditionally religious, but spiritual themes lie embedded in his scientific secularism. This chapter explores how Kohut locates empathy and introspection in mystical traditions. Embedded in Kohut’s writing is the directive not just to empathize but also to “love thy neighbor as thyself.” Kohut believed religious symbols nourished the human heart and psyche and were connected with the human need to idealize others. Kohut thought religion could be a positive force in culture. The chapter discusses Kohut’s ideas regarding wisdom, humor, and acceptance of transience as at the core of a healthy sense of self. His thoughts regarding mortality culminate in Kohut’s important idea of Tragic Man, in contrast to Freud’s Guilty Man. Kohut’s spirituality has far-reaching relevance in contemporary psychoanalysis, where more patients are seeking out a spiritual dimension to psychoanalytic treatment.