Unravelling interobserver variability in gastrointestinal glandular neoplasia: a contemporary study of US and Korean pathologists
- 22 September 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by BMJ in Journal of Clinical Pathology
- Vol. 77 (12) , 842-847
Abstract
Aims Interobserver variability in the assessment of gastric neoplasia biopsies between most Western and Eastern (predominantly represented by Japanese in the literature) pathologists has been documented. It is unknown if such variability exists between the US and Korean pathologists in the current era. Methods Ten gastrointestinal (GI) pathologists from the USA (n=5) and South Korea (n=5) evaluated 100 scanned images of gastric (n=50) and colorectal (n=50) neoplasia biopsies and answered multiple questionnaires. Consensus was defined as the answer chosen by the majority. Cohen’s (κc) and Fleiss’ kappa (κf) values were calculated between the consensus of the two groups and among the raters, respectively. Results Both groups reached a consensus in the majority of cases (74%–100%) with slight to perfect intergroup (κc=0.049–1.000) and no to substantial intragroup (κf=−0.083 to 0.660) agreements. For gastric neoplasia, Korean pathologists relied heavily on cytoarchitectural atypia, whereas the US pathologists focused on stromal invasion when diagnosing adenocarcinoma. For colorectal neoplasia, the Korean pathologists identified concurrent intramucosal carcinoma when diagnosing invasive adenocarcinoma, while the presence of desmoplasia was a prerequisite for the diagnosis of invasive adenocarcinoma for the US pathologists. Conclusions For GI neoplasia biopsy interpretation, the diagnostic approach of Korean pathologists is similar to that of Eastern/Japanese pathologists. Consensus outperformed kappa statistics in capturing the magnitude of inter-rater and intergroup reliability, highlighting the potential benefit of consensus meetings to decrease the gap between Western and Eastern diagnostic approaches.Keywords
This publication has 23 references indexed in Scilit:
- High-grade Dysplasia Versus CarcinomaAmerican Journal of Surgical Pathology, 2014
- Gastric High-grade Dysplasia Can Be Associated With Submucosal InvasionAmerican Journal of Surgical Pathology, 2014
- Desmoplastic reaction in biopsy specimens of early colorectal cancer: A Japanese prospective multicenter studyPathology International, 2012
- Diagnosis of gastric epithelial neoplasia: Dilemma for Korean pathologistsWorld Journal of Gastroenterology, 2011
- Interobserver Variation in the Diagnosis of Gastric Epithelial Dysplasia and Carcinoma between Two Pathologists in Japan and KoreaJournal of Gastric Cancer, 2011
- Measuring the Value of Review of Pathology Material by a Second PathologistAmerican Journal of Clinical Pathology, 2006
- Intraglandular necrotic debris in gastric biopsy and surgical specimensAnnals of Diagnostic Pathology, 2001
- The Vienna classification of gastrointestinal epithelial neoplasiaGut, 2000
- Evaluation of Gastric Biopsies for NeoplasiaAmerican Journal of Surgical Pathology, 1999
- Differences in diagnostic criteria for gastric carcinoma between Japanese and Western pathologistsThe Lancet, 1997