Risk-Benefit Analysis and the Net Risks Test

Authors:
  • DWDavid Wendler
    David Wendler
  • FMFranklin G Miller
    Franklin G Miller

Abstract
The goal of clinical research is to develop scientific knowledge that can guide the improvement of medical care for future patients. A central concern in research ethics is to protect participants from exploitation in the course of this socially valuable activity. To avoid exploitation, the risks to which research participants are exposed must be reasonable in relation to anticipated benefits. This requirement raises a host of difficult questions. Must the potential clinical benefits to participants outweigh the risks they face? Or is it ethically acceptable to expose participants to some risks for the benefit of society? Assuming it is ethical to expose participants to some risks for the benefit of society, are there limits on the level of these risks? And if there are such limits, to what extent do they vary depending upon the participants in question, whether they can consent or not, whether they are children or not?