Environmental uncertainty and forward integration in marketing: theory and meta‐analysis
Authors:
- 10 February 2012
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Emerald Publishing in European Journal of Marketing
- Vol. 46 (1/2) , 5-30
Abstract
Purpose: This paper aims to present a meta‐analysis to test the competing hypotheses that arise from structural contingency theory (SCT) and transaction cost analysis (TCA) about how environmental uncertainty affects the strategic marketing policy of forward vertical integration (VI).Design/methodology/approach: The meta‐analysis focuses on directional hypothesis tests rather than effect sizes in a set of 84 tests drawn from 29 published studies. It employs the C‐OAR elements of Rossiter's C‐OAR‐SE framework to validate construct definitions and their measures within these studies.Findings: Although the results confirm the TCA hypothesis that asset specificity favours forward VI, the results for the effect of environmental uncertainty on forward VI do not favour either of the two competing hypotheses, but instead show that methodological orientation, international context, and historical time period moderate effects across studies and tests.Research limitations/implications: The findings imply that the relative ability of SCT and TCA to predict the effect of environmental uncertainty on forward VI in marketing may reflect real historical patterns of integration activity as a response to uncertain environments. In particular, in a new economy characterised by globalisation and rapid technological change, an increasing number of industries may face levels of uncertainty so high that they are increasingly less manageable through forward VI, a situation that broadly though tentatively favours the SCT prediction.Originality/value: Since no single empirical study has explicitly tested the implied competing uncertainty hypotheses from SCT and TCA, and since published meta‐analyses of VI have only considered the TCA hypothesis and never the competing SCT hypothesis and have in every instance pooled studies of backward and forward VI, this study develops a meta‐analysis for this purpose.Keywords
This publication has 59 references indexed in Scilit:
- The C-OAR-SE procedure for scale development in marketingInternational Journal of Research in Marketing, 2002
- The Hierarchical Model of Market Entry ModesJournal of International Business Studies, 2000
- Comparative versus Noncomparative Advertising: A Meta-AnalysisJournal of Marketing, 1997
- Vertical Integration in the Property-Liability Insurance Industry: A Transaction Cost ApproachJournal of Risk and Insurance, 1997
- Large company capital formation and effects of market share turbulence : micro-data evidence from the PIMS databaseApplied Economics, 1996
- THEORY TESTING: COMBINING PSYCHOMETRIC META‐ANALYSIS AND STRUCTURAL EQUATIONS MODELINGPersonnel Psychology, 1995
- Order of Entry and Business Performance: An Empirical Synthesis and ReexaminationJournal of Marketing, 1995
- The Design of Replicated StudiesThe American Statistician, 1993
- Environmental Determinants of Decision-Making Uncertainty in Marketing ChannelsJournal of Marketing Research, 1988
- Organizational Economics: Notes on the Use of Transaction-Cost Theory in the Study of OrganizationsAdministrative Science Quarterly, 1987