Evaluating the Quality and Comparative Validity of Manual Food Logging and Artificial Intelligence-Enabled Food Image Recognition in Apps for Nutrition Care
Open Access
Abstract
For artificial intelligence (AI) to support nutrition care, high quality and accuracy of its features within smartphone applications (apps) are essential. This study evaluated popular apps’ features, quality, behaviour change potential, and comparative validity of dietary assessment via manual logging and AI. The top 200 free and paid nutrition-related apps from Australia’s Apple App and Google Play stores were screened (n = 800). Apps were assessed using MARS (quality) and ABACUS (behaviour change potential). Nutritional outputs from manual food logging and AI-enabled food-image recognition apps were compared with food records for Western, Asian, and Recommended diets. Among 18 apps, Noom scored highest on MARS (mean = 4.44) and ABACUS (21/21). From 16 manual food-logging apps, energy was overestimated for Western (mean: 1040 kJ) but underestimated for Asian (mean: −1520 kJ) diets. MyFitnessPal and Fastic had the highest accuracy (97% and 92%, respectively) out of seven AI-enabled food image recognition apps. Apps with more AI integration demonstrated better functionality, but automatic energy estimations from AI-enabled food image recognition were inaccurate. To enhance the integration of apps into nutrition care, collaborating with dietitians is essential for improving their credibility and comparative validity by expanding food databases. Moreover, training AI models are needed to improve AI-enabled food recognition, especially for mixed dishes and culturally diverse foods.Keywords
This publication has 70 references indexed in Scilit:
- AI nutritionist: Intelligent software as the next generation pioneer of precision nutritionComputers in Biology and Medicine, 2024
- Artificial intelligence & clinical nutrition: What the future might have in storeClinical Nutrition ESPEN, 2023
- Smartphone apps for tracking food consumption and recommendations: Evaluating artificial intelligence-based functionalities, features and quality of current appsIntelligent Systems with Applications, 2022
- Comparative Validity of Mostly Unprocessed and Minimally Processed Food Items Differs Among Popular Commercial Nutrition Apps Compared with a Research Food DatabaseJournal of the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics, 2022
- The Age of Artificial Intelligence: Use of Digital Technology in Clinical NutritionCurrent Surgery Reports, 2021
- Use of mobile applications to improve nutrition behaviour: A systematic reviewComputer Methods and Programs in Biomedicine, 2020
- Assessment of nutrition-focused mobile apps' influence on consumers' healthy food behaviour and nutrition knowledgeFood Research International, 2020
- The Effects of Dietary Mobile Apps on Nutritional Outcomes in Adults with Chronic Diseases: A Systematic Review and Meta-AnalysisJournal of the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics, 2019
- Image-Assisted Dietary Assessment: A Systematic Review of the EvidenceJournal of the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics, 2015
- Weight loss—there is an app for that! But does it adhere to evidence-informed practices?Translational Behavioral Medicine, 2011