Rethinking Economic Foundations for Sustainable Development: A Comprehensive Assessment of Six Economic Paradigms Against the SDGs
Open Access
- 16 May 2025
- journal article
- research article
- Published by MDPI AG in Sustainability
- Vol. 17 (10) , 4567
Abstract
Progress toward achieving the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) has been disappointingly slow, raising fundamental questions about whether our dominant economic framework can deliver sustainable development outcomes. This research systematically evaluates six economic paradigms—Neoclassical Welfare Economics, Green Growth, Degrowth, Agrowth, Steady State Economics, and Doughnut Economics—against all 17 SDGs to determine which might better support sustainability transformations. Using a rigorous mixed-methods approach, we first characterize each paradigm according to key attributes, then assess their alignment with SDG objectives using a four-point scoring system. Our analysis reveals that the dominant Neoclassical Welfare Economics paradigm shows the weakest alignment with the SDGs, while alternative frameworks demonstrate significantly stronger alignment: Degrowth, Steady State Economics, Doughnut Economics, Green Growth, and Agrowth. No single paradigm fully addresses all dimensions of sustainable development, with most showing notable weaknesses in people-centered SDGs. Each paradigm demonstrates distinct complementary strengths: Green Growth in technological innovation, Degrowth in redistribution mechanisms, Steady State Economics in resource boundaries, Agrowth in redefining welfare, and Doughnut Economics in balancing social foundations with ecological ceilings. We conclude that selective integration of complementary elements from multiple paradigms offers the most promising pathway forward and propose four specific recommendations: (1) developing integrated assessment frameworks, (2) establishing experimental policy zones, (3) reforming economics education, and (4) creating context-specific transition pathways. This research provides the first comprehensive evaluation of how alternative economic paradigms align with the full spectrum of SDGs, offering crucial guidance for policymakers seeking more effective approaches to sustainable development.Keywords
This publication has 92 references indexed in Scilit:
- A balancing act between economic growth and sustainable development: Historical trajectory through the lens of development indicatorsSustainable Development, 2022
- Introduction to welfare economicsPublic Choice, 2018
- Governing the Interlinkages between the Sustainable Development Goals: Approaches to Attain Policy IntegrationGlobal Challenges, 2017
- Postgrowth and Wellbeing2017
- The Great Mindshift2016
- Towards Integration at Last? The Sustainable Development Goals as a Network of TargetsSustainable Development, 2015
- Transdisciplinary research in sustainability science: practice, principles, and challengesSustainability Science, 2012
- What about the politics? Sustainable development, transition management, and long term energy transitionsPolicy Sciences, 2009
- Systematic Reviews in the Social Sciences2006
- From preference to happiness: Towards a more complete welfare economicsSocial Choice and Welfare, 2003