Two negatives don't always make a positive: Exploring how limitations in teacher knowledge and the curriculum contribute to instructional quality
Authors:
- Charalambos Y. CharalambousCCCharalambos Y. Charalambous
- Heather C. HillHHHeather C. Hill
- Rebecca N. MitchellRMRebecca N. Mitchell
- 23 August 2012
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Curriculum Studies
- Vol. 44 (4) , 489-513
Abstract
This paper examines the contribution of mathematical knowledge for teaching (MKT) and curriculum materials to the implementation of lessons on integer subtraction. In particular, it investigates the instruction of three teachers with differing MKT levels using two editions of the same set of curriculum materials that provided different levels of support. This variation in MKT level and curriculum support facilitated exploring the distinct and joint contribution of MKT and the curriculum materials to instructional quality. The analyses suggest that MKT relates positively to teachers' use of representations, provision of explanations, precision in language and notation, and ability to capitalize on student contributions and move the mathematics along in a goal-directed manner. Curriculum materials set the stage for attending to the meaning of integer subtraction and appeared to support teachers' use of representations, provision of explanations, and precision in language and notation. More critically, the findings suggest that less educative curriculum materials, coupled with low levels of MKT, can lead to problematic instruction. In contrast, educative materials can help low-MKT teachers provide adequate instruction, while higher MKT levels seem to enable teachers to compensate for curriculum limitations.Keywords
This publication has 8 references indexed in Scilit:
- Curriculum-Context Knowledge: Teacher Learning From Successive Enactments of a Standards-Based Mathematics CurriculumCurriculum Inquiry, 2009
- Mathematical Knowledge for Teaching and the Mathematical Quality of Instruction: An Exploratory StudyCognition and Instruction, 2008
- Mathematical Knowledge for Teaching Fraction MultiplicationCognition and Instruction, 2008
- A Context for Integer ComputationMathematics Teaching in the Middle School, 2007
- Understanding and Learning-to-explain by Representing Mathematics: Epistemological Dilemmas Facing Teacher Educators in the Secondary Mathematics ``Methods'' CourseJournal of Mathematics Teacher Education, 2002
- Can Curriculum Materials Support Teachers' Learning? Two Fourth-Grade Teachers' Use of a New Mathematics TextThe Elementary School Journal, 2000
- Positives About Negatives: A Case Study of an Intermediate Model for Signed NumbersJournal of the Learning Sciences, 1994
- With an Eye on the Mathematical Horizon: Dilemmas of Teaching Elementary School MathematicsThe Elementary School Journal, 1993