“Even if My Voice Shakes, I'm Still Going to Say It”: How Elementary Literacy Educators in Texas Enact Criticality Using Children's Literature
Open Access
- 28 August 2025
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Reading Research Quarterly
- Vol. 60 (4)
Abstract
Critical K‐12 educators who teach students to question the status quo have always faced censorship, rebuke, and potential loss of livelihood. This risk is particularly heightened in conservative areas, like Texas, where ideological opposition to equity often results in legislative threats to ban literature and censor curriculum that addresses diverse histories and realities. Despite these challenges, literacy organizations encourage educators to “transform” and “humanize” education to achieve social justice. This study explores how two Texas elementary literacy teachers, Ms. Martinez and Ms. Smith, enacted critical pedagogies during their daily read‐alouds focused on immigration, a pressing sociopolitical issue in their communities. Drawing on Brown's (2013) theory of humanizing critical sociocultural knowledge (HCSK) and Kumashiro's (2001) anti‐oppressive education framework, the year‐long multi‐case study included 53 read‐aloud observations, classroom artifacts, and interviews. Findings show that these educators selected literature aligned with their values, using it to facilitate critical discussions about humanizing immigrants and refugees. Rather than relying on “perfect” texts, the teachers used a mix of older, less radical books and their own expertise to provoke inquiry and dialog from the students. I found that Ms. Martinez and Ms. Smith stood in front , rather than behind , the texts they read aloud to their students. They positioned themselves as co‐conspirators, guiding students to critically engage with stories and encouraging them to ask questions about the narratives they encountered at home, in school, and in the broader world. This paper demonstrates how critical pedagogies can flourish when educators have the flexibility and confidence to navigate contentious issues using their well‐developed HCSK, offering a model for resisting censorship and promoting liberation in restrictive educational climates.Keywords
This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- Enacting Reading Comprehension: Using Diverse Literature to Engage Children's Critical, Sociopolitical KnowledgeReading Research Quarterly, 2024
- “A Good Text with a Well-Intended Teacher”: New Educators Developing and Deepening Social Justice Literature PedagogiesThe New Educator, 2024
- Positions, positionality, and relationality in educational researchInternational Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education, 2023
- “Harmful to Minors” : How Book Bans Hurt Adolescent DevelopmentThe Serials Librarian, 2023
- Critical content knowledges in the English language arts classroom: examining practicing teachers' nuanced perspectivesJournal of Curriculum Studies, 2020
- Teaching Contentious Books Regarding Immigration: The Case of Pancho RabbitThe Reading Teacher, 2018
- Examining the immigrant experience: helping teachers develop as critical educatorsTeaching Education, 2013
- Trouble on my mind: toward a framework of humanizing critical sociocultural knowledge for teaching and teacher educationRace Ethnicity and Education, 2013
- Diverse Learners, Diverse Texts: Exploring Identity and Difference through Literary EncountersJournal of Literacy Research, 1998
- Social Class and the Hidden Curriculum of WorkJournal of Education, 1980