Recent studies suggest that older adults maintain high levels of state curiosity when presented with epistemic materials, despite age-related declines in personality traits related to curiosity. We hypothesized that this age-related preservation in state curiosity is explained by older adults’ rich prior knowledge, given that knowledge acts as a key driver of state curiosity across the adult lifespan. To test this idea, we conducted two experiments that examined older and younger adults’ curiosity to learn the answers to questions in low- and high-knowledge domains. Experiment 1 (N = 216) used learning materials characterized by large population-level differences in prior knowledge, but limited variation across age groups. The results showed that prior knowledge substantially affects state curiosity, irrespective of age, while the effect of age on state curiosity was minimal. Experiment 2 (N = 216) explicitly accounted for age differences in knowledge by orthogonalizing the effects of knowledge and age. We found that relative to younger adults, older adults experienced stronger curiosity for high-knowledge domains, whereas in other domains where younger adults were more knowledgeable, older adults experienced weaker curiosity relative to younger adults. Such age-related differences in curiosity were mediated by age-related differences in knowledge. These findings point to the important role of prior knowledge in curiosity across younger and older adults, extending theoretical notions on curiosity. Our results also suggest that previously observed age differences in state curiosity might be partly attributable to age-related differences in knowledge.