A Randomized Comparison Trial of Case‐based Learning versus Human Patient Simulation in Medical Student Education
Authors:
- Rosemarie FernandezRFRosemarie Fernandez
- Sarkis R. KouyoumjianSKSarkis R. Kouyoumjian
- Kerin A. JonesKJKerin A. Jones
- Scott ComptonSCScott Compton
- 1 February 2007
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Academic Emergency Medicine
- Vol. 14 (2) , 130-137
Abstract
ObjectivesHuman patient simulation (HPS), utilizing computerized, physiologically responding mannequins, has become the latest innovation in medical education. However, no substantive outcome data exist validating the advantage of HPS. The objective of this study was to evaluate the efficacy of simulation training as compared with case‐based learning (CBL) among fourth‐year medical students as measured by observable behavioral actions.MethodsA chest pain curriculum was presented during a one‐month mandatory emergency medicine clerkship in 2005. Each month, students were randomized to participate in either the CBL‐based or the HPS‐based module. All students participated in the same end‐of‐clerkship chest pain objective structured clinical examination that measured 43 behaviors. Three subscales were computed: history taking, acute coronary syndrome evaluation and management, and cardiac arrest management. Mean total and subscale scores were compared across groups using a multivariate analysis of variance, with significance assessed from Hotelling's T2 statistic.ResultsStudents were randomly assigned to CBL (n= 52) or HPS (n= 50) groups. The groups were well balanced after random assignment, with no differences in mean age (26.7 years; range, 22–44 years), gender (male, 52.0%), or emergency medicine preference for specialty training (28.4%). Self‐ratings of learning styles were similar overall: 54.9% were visual learners, 7.8% auditory learners, and 37.3% kinetic learners. Results of the multivariate analysis of variance indicated no significant effect (Hotelling's T2 [3,98] = 0.053; p = 0.164) of education modality (CBL or HPS) on any subscale or total score difference in performance.ConclusionsHPS training offers no advantage to CBL as measured by medical student performance on a chest pain objective structured clinical examination.Keywords
This publication has 23 references indexed in Scilit:
- The history of simulation in medical education and possible future directionsMedical Education, 2006
- Features and uses of high-fidelity medical simulations that lead to effective learning: a BEME systematic reviewMedical Teacher, 2005
- Using Simulation to Instruct Emergency Medicine Residents in Cognitive Forcing StrategiesAcademic Medicine, 2004
- Experience with medical student simulation educationCritical Care Medicine, 2004
- Raising the Passing Grade for Studies of Medical EducationJAMA, 2003
- Emergency Medicine Crisis Resource Management (EMCRM): Pilot Study of a Simulation-based Crisis Management Course for Emergency MedicineAcademic Emergency Medicine, 2003
- Education On-demandAcademic Medicine, 2002
- Teaching professional development in medical schoolsThe Lancet, 2001
- The Human Patient Simulator™Academic Medicine, 2000
- Sample Size Requirements for theT2Test of MANOVA (Tables for One‐way Classification)Biometrical Journal, 1978