Role of knowledge and reasoning processes as predictors of resident physicians’ susceptibility to anchoring bias in diagnostic reasoning: a randomised controlled experiment
- 16 February 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by BMJ in BMJ Quality & Safety
- Vol. 33 (9) , 563-572
Abstract
Background Diagnostic errors have been attributed to reasoning flaws caused by cognitive biases. While experiments have shown bias to cause errors, physicians of similar expertise differed in susceptibility to bias. Resisting bias is often said to depend on engaging analytical reasoning, disregarding the influence of knowledge. We examined the role of knowledge and reasoning mode, indicated by diagnosis time and confidence, as predictors of susceptibility to anchoring bias. Anchoring bias occurs when physicians stick to an incorrect diagnosis triggered by early salient distracting features (SDF) despite subsequent conflicting information. Methods Sixty-eight internal medicine residents from two Dutch university hospitals participated in a two-phase experiment. Phase 1: assessment of knowledge of discriminating features (ie, clinical findings that discriminate between lookalike diseases) for six diseases. Phase 2 (1 week later): diagnosis of six cases of these diseases. Each case had two versions differing exclusively in the presence/absence of SDF. Each participant diagnosed three cases with SDF (SDF+) and three without (SDF−). Participants were randomly allocated to case versions. Based on phase 1 assessment, participants were split into higher knowledge or lower knowledge groups. Main outcome measurements: frequency of diagnoses associated with SDF; time to diagnose; and confidence in diagnosis. Results While both knowledge groups performed similarly on SDF- cases, higher knowledge physicians succumbed to anchoring bias less frequently than their lower knowledge counterparts on SDF+ cases (p=0.02). Overall, physicians spent more time (pConclusions Physicians apparently adopted a more analytical reasoning approach when presented with distracting features, indicated by increased time and lower confidence, trying to combat bias. Yet, extended deliberation alone did not explain the observed performance differences between knowledge groups. Success in mitigating anchoring bias was primarily predicted by knowledge of discriminating features of diagnoses.Keywords
This publication has 53 references indexed in Scilit:
- The epidemiology of malpractice claims in primary care: a systematic reviewBMJ Open, 2013
- Identifying early warning signs for diagnostic errors in primary care: a qualitative studyBMJ Open, 2012
- Exploring the role of salient distracting clinical features in the emergence of diagnostic errors and the mechanisms through which reflection counteracts mistakesBMJ Quality & Safety, 2012
- Bias and ConflictPerspectives on Psychological Science, 2012
- Swapping Horses Midstream: Factors Related to Physiciansʼ Changing Their Minds About a DiagnosisAcademic Medicine, 2010
- In conflict with ourselves? An investigation of heuristic and analytic processes in decision makingMemory & Cognition, 2010
- Overconfidence as a Cause of Diagnostic Error in MedicineThe American Journal of Medicine, 2008
- Conflict monitoring in dual process theories of thinkingCognition, 2008
- The Influence of Irrelevant Anchors on the Judgments and Choices of Doctors and PatientsMedical Decision Making, 2007
- Adapting to the Euro: Evidence from bias reductionJournal of Economic Psychology, 2003