We set forth a new theory for understanding the consequences of CEO celebrity. The fulcrum of our theory is the reality that CEOs attain celebrity because of specific outsized styles, or types, of leadership or accomplishment, rather than for general or abstract achievements. We highlight two such types of celebrity CEOs, the creator and the savior, and argue that one’s type sets off a cascade of accompanying tendencies. These outgrowths of celebrity span the socio-cognitive (including social pressure to remain true to type) and the behavioral (including tendencies to persist with and even exaggerate prior celebrity-garnering actions), ultimately constraining the strategic repertoires of celebrity CEOs. In turn, we argue that the effects of CEO celebrity on firm performance are contingent on continuity of external and internal contextual conditions. If conditions change appreciably, the celebrity CEO’s socio-cognitive and behavioral rigidities, or shackles, become severe liabilities, explaining the documented tendency for CEO celebrity to bring about, on average, unfavorable firm outcomes. We discuss the practical implications of our theory and present an inventory of research opportunities.