Providing a brief corrective statement does not improve test performance in patients invalidating testing: A multisite, single-blind randomized controlled trial
Open Access
- 26 July 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The Clinical Neuropsychologist
- Vol. 39 (2) , 324-346
Abstract
Objective: Performance below the actual abilities of the examinee can be measured using performance validity tests (PVTs). PVT failure negatively impacts the quality of the neuropsychological assessment. In our study, we addressed this issue by providing a brief corrective statement regarding invalidity to improve test-taking behavior. Methods: This study is a multisite single-blind randomized controlled trial in a consecutive sample of clinically referred adult patients (N = 196) in a general hospital setting. Patients who failed a PVT (n = 71) were randomly allocated to a corrective statement approach (CS; n = 39), in which a brief verbal corrective statement was given by the technician, or received no corrective statement upon indications of invalid performance (NO-CS; n = 32). Both groups (CS and NO-CS) were provided with the same subsequently repeated and newly administered tests. Results: There were no group (CS vs. NO-CS) differences on both the repeated and single-administered PVTs and standard cognitive tests. Furthermore, invalid performing participants benefited significantly less from the repeated test administration compared to the valid performing group. Conclusions: Our study found that a brief corrective within-session statement, to address PVT failure and improve test-taking behavior, did not improve consequent test performance. These results suggest limited value of a brief verbal corrective statement to influence performance below best of capabilities. It highlights the need for more research to identify more effective approaches that can enhance patients test-taking behavior. Ultimately, such efforts are critical in ensuring accurate diagnosis and effective treatment recommendations for patients.Keywords
This publication has 32 references indexed in Scilit:
- Performance Validity Test Failure in the Clinical Population: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Prevalence RatesNeuropsychology Review, 2023
- The psychological benefits of neuropsychological assessment feedback as a psycho-educational therapeutic intervention: A randomized-controlled trial with cross-over in multiple sclerosisNeuropsychological Rehabilitation, 2022
- A Scoping Review of Communicating Neuropsychological Test Results to Patients and Family MembersNeuropsychology Review, 2021
- Performance validity and symptom validity tests: Are they measuring different constructs?Neuropsychology, 2021
- Psychological Symptoms and Rates of Performance Validity Improve Following Trauma-Focused Treatment in Veterans with PTSD and History of Mild-to-Moderate TBIJournal of the International Neuropsychological Society, 2019
- Normative data for the Animal, Profession and Letter M Naming verbal fluency tests for Dutch speaking participants and the effects of age, education, and sexJournal of the International Neuropsychological Society, 2006
- Rey's verbal learning test: Normative data for 1855 healthy participants aged 24–81 years and the influence of age, sex, education, and mode of presentationJournal of the International Neuropsychological Society, 2005
- Improvement or simply practice? The effects of twenty repeated assessments on people with and without brain injuryJournal of the International Neuropsychological Society, 2000
- Self-reported physical activity, subjective health, and cognitive performance in older adultsExperimental Aging Research, 1996
- Learning and Retrieval Rate of Words Presented Auditorily and VisuallyThe Journal of General Psychology, 1985