Beyond Plagiarism: Transgressive and Nontransgressive Intertextuality
Authors:
- Ranamukalage ChandrasomaRCRanamukalage Chandrasoma
- Celia ThompsonCTCelia Thompson
- Alastair PennycookAPAlastair Pennycook
- 1 July 2004
- journal article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Language, Identity & Education
- Vol. 3 (3) , 171-193
Abstract
The debate about what constitutes plagiarism and how it should be dealt with in the academy continues to gain momentum. The response from many higher education institutions is to channel ever-increasing amounts of resources into plagiarism detection technologies, rather than trying to ascertain why plagiarism might be occurring in the first place. In this article, drawing on a wide range of data from student assignments and interviews with staff and students, we argue that it would be preferable to do away with the notion of plagiarism in favour of an understanding of transgressive and nontransgressive intertextuality. Once textual borrowings are seen in this light, we are more able to focus on the crucial issues of writing, identity, power, knowledge, disciplinary dynamics, and discourse that underlie intertextuality. We conclude that judgements about the nature of intertextuality are contextually contingent; they should also be understood as part of a broader account of institutional regulation and stud...Keywords
This publication has 35 references indexed in Scilit:
- Options of identity in academic writingELT Journal, 2002
- Dealing with plagiarism when giving feedbackELT Journal, 2001
- ESL Writers Discuss Plagiarism: The Social Construction of IdeologiesJournal of Education, 2000
- Ownership Revisited: An Exploration in Progressive Era and Expressivist Composition ScholarshipCollege Composition and Communication, 1998
- Writing and Identity1998
- Staying out of trouble: Apparent plagiarism and academic survivalJournal of Second Language Writing, 1998
- Safe Houses in the Contact Zone: Coping Strategies of African-American Students in the AcademyCollege Composition and Communication, 1997
- Second Language Acquisition of Spoken and Written English: Acquiring the SkeptronTESOL Quarterly, 1997
- Plagiarisms, Authorships, and the Academic Death PenaltyCollege English, 1995
- Plagiarism: The Worm of ReasonCollege English, 1983