Transportal central femoral tunnel placement has a significantly higher revision rate than transtibial AM femoral tunnel placement in hamstring ACL reconstruction
Authors:
- 12 July 2018
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Knee Surgery, Sports Traumatology, Arthroscopy
- Vol. 27 (1) , 124-129
Abstract
Purpose: It is proposed that central femoral ACL graft placement better controls rotational stability. This study evaluates the consequence of changing the femoral tunnel position from the AM position drilled transtibially to the central position drilled transportally. The difference in ACL graft failure is reported.Methods: This prospective consecutive patient single surgeon study compares the revision rates of 1016 transtibial hamstring ACL reconstructions followed for 6–15 years with 464 transportal hamstring ACL reconstructions followed for 2–6 years. Sex, age, graft size, time to surgery, meniscal repair and meniscectomy data were evaluated as contributing factors for ACL graft failure to enable a multivariate analysis. To adjust for the variable follow‐up a multivariate hazard ratio, failure per 100 graft years and Kaplan–Meier survivorship was determined.Results: With transtibial ACLR 52/1016 failed (5.1%). With transportal ACLR 32/464 failed (6.9%). Significant differences between transportal and transtibial ACLR were seen for graft diameter, time to surgery, medial meniscal repair rates and meniscal tissue remaining after meniscectomy. Adjusting for these the multivariate hazard ratio was 2.3 times higher in the transportal group (p = 0.001). Central tunnel placement resulted in a significantly 3.5 times higher revision rate compared to an anteromedial tunnel placement per 100 graft years (p = 0.001). Five year survival was 980/1016 (96.5%) for transtibial versus 119/131 (90.5%) for transportal. Transportal ACLR also showed a significantly higher earlier failure rate with 20/32 (61%) of the transportal failing in the first year compared with 14/52 (27%) for transtibial. (p = 0.001.)Conclusion: Transportal central femoral tunnel ACLR has a higher failure rate and earlier failure than transtibial AM femoral tunnel ACLR.Level of evidence: Level II—prospective comparative study.Keywords
This publication has 29 references indexed in Scilit:
- Comparison of 2 Femoral Tunnel Locations in Anatomic Single‐Bundle Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction: A Biomechanical StudyArthroscopy, 2012
- Anatomical versus Non-Anatomical Single Bundle Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction: A Cadaveric Study of Comparison of Knee StabilityClinics in Orthopedic Surgery, 2012
- Biomechanical Comparison of Anatomic Double-Bundle, Anatomic Single-Bundle, and Nonanatomic Single-Bundle Anterior Cruciate Ligament ReconstructionsThe American Journal of Sports Medicine, 2011
- Transtibial Versus Anteromedial Portal Reaming in Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction: An Anatomic and Biomechanical Evaluation of Surgical TechniqueArthroscopy, 2010
- Direct Anterior Cruciate Ligament Insertion to the Femur Assessed by Histology and 3‐Dimensional Volume‐Rendered Computed TomographyArthroscopy, 2010
- A Comparison of 11 O'clock versus Oblique Femoral Tunnels in the Anterior Cruciate Ligament—Reconstructed KneeThe American Journal of Sports Medicine, 2010
- Contributions of the Posterolateral Bundle of the Anterior Cruciate Ligament to Anterior‐Posterior Knee Laxity and Ligament ForcesArthroscopy, 2008
- Comparison of 3-Dimensional Obliquity and Anisometric Characteristics of Anterior Cruciate Ligament Graft Positions Using Surgical NavigationThe American Journal of Sports Medicine, 2008
- Varying Femoral Tunnels between the Anatomical Footprint and Isometric PositionsThe American Journal of Sports Medicine, 2005
- Factors affecting the region of most isometric femoral attachmentsThe American Journal of Sports Medicine, 1989