When neuromodulation met control theory
Authors:
- Roberto GuidottiRGRoberto Guidotti
- Alessio BastiABAlessio Basti
- Giulia PieramicoGPGiulia Pieramico
- Antea D’aNdreaADAntea D’aNdrea
- Saeed MakkinayeriSMSaeed Makkinayeri
- Mauro PettorrusoMauro Pettorruso
- Timo RoineTRTimo Roine
- Ulf ZiemannUZUlf Ziemann
- Risto J IlmoniemiRIRisto J Ilmoniemi
- Vittorio PizzellaVPVittorio Pizzella
- Laura MarzettiLMLaura Marzetti
Open Access
- 1 February 2025
- journal article
- Published by IOP Publishing in Journal of Neural Engineering
- Vol. 22 (1) , 011001
Abstract
The brain is a highly complex physical system made of assemblies of neurons that work together to accomplish elaborate tasks such as motor control, memory and perception. How these parts work together has been studied for decades by neuroscientists using neuroimaging, psychological manipulations, and neurostimulation. Neurostimulation has gained particular interest, given the possibility to perturb the brain and elicit a specific response. This response depends on different parameters such as the intensity, the location and the timing of the stimulation. However, most of the studies performed so far used previously established protocols without considering the ongoing brain activity and, thus, without adaptively targeting the stimulation. In control theory, this approach is called open-loop control, and it is always paired with a different form of control called closed-loop, in which the current activity of the brain is used to establish the next stimulation. Recently, neuroscientists are beginning to shift from classical fixed neuromodulation studies to closed-loop experiments. This new approach allows the control of brain activity based on responses to stimulation and thus to personalize individual treatment in clinical conditions. Here, we review this new approach by introducing control theory and focusing on how these aspects are applied in brain studies. We also present the different stimulation techniques and the control approaches used to steer the brain. Finally, we explore how the closed-loop framework will revolutionize the way the human brain can be studied, including a discussion on open questions and an outlook on future advances.Keywords
Funding Information
- European Research Council (810377)
- NextGenerationEU (D53D2301926000)
This publication has 168 references indexed in Scilit:
- The impact of aging on human brain network target controllabilityBrain Structure and Function, 2022
- Online closed‐loop real‐time tES‐fMRI for brain modulation: A technical reportBrain and Behavior, 2022
- Adaptive parameter modulation of deep brain stimulation in a computational model of basal ganglia–thalamic networkNonlinear Dynamics, 2021
- Properties and temporal dynamics of choice- and action-predictive signals during item recognition decisionsBrain Structure and Function, 2020
- „ConnectToBrain“Der Nervenarzt, 2019
- Real‐time estimation of dynamic functional connectivity networksHuman Brain Mapping, 2016
- Inter-subject and Inter-session Variability of Plasticity Induction by Non-invasive Brain Stimulation: Boon or Bane?Brain Stimulation, 2015
- Variability in Response to Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation of the Motor CortexBrain Stimulation, 2014
- Adaptive deep brain stimulation in advanced Parkinson diseaseAnnals of Neurology, 2013
- Perspectives on system identificationAnnual Reviews in Control, 2010