Getting blood from a stone: Improving brain–behavior inferences without brain data
Authors:
Open Access
- 23 September 2026
- journal article
- Published by MIT Press in Imaging Neuroscience
- Vol. 4
Abstract
In recent years, the cognitive neuroscience literature has come under criticism for containing many low-powered studies, limiting the ability to make reliable statistical inferences. Typically, the suggestion for increasing power is to collect more data with neural signals. However, many studies in cognitive neuroscience use parameters estimated from behavioral data in order to make inferences about neural signals (such as fMRI BOLD signal). In this paper, we explore how cognitive neuroscientists can learn more about their neuroimaging signal by collecting data on behavior alone and using alternative estimators designed to leverage this information. We demonstrate through simulation and mathematical derivations that knowing more about the marginal distribution of behavior can improve inferences about the mapping between cognitive processes and neural data. We analyze the magnitude of this benefit, finding that it depends on the desired estimand and several underlying study parameters. While in many cases the absolute gains in precision can be modest, our results demonstrate that, in realistic settings, additional behavioral data can lead to the same improvement in the precision of inferences more cheaply and easily than collecting additional data from subjects in a neuroimaging study. This means that when conducting a neuroimaging study, researchers now have another knob to turn in a design analysis: the number of subjects collected in the scanner and the number of behavioral subjects collected outside the scanner (in the laboratory or online).Keywords
Funding Information
- National Science Foundation (DRL-1631436)
This publication has 60 references indexed in Scilit:
- Power and design considerations in imaging research2019
- Intraclass correlation: Improved modeling approaches and applications for neuroimagingHuman Brain Mapping, 2017
- A Flexible and Efficient Hierarchical Bayesian Approach to the Exploration of Individual Differences in Cognitive‐model‐based Neuroscience2017
- Model-based cognitive neuroscienceJournal of Mathematical Psychology, 2017
- How hierarchical models improve point estimates of model parameters at the individual levelJournal of Mathematical Psychology, 2016
- Approaches to analysis in model-based cognitive neuroscienceJournal of Mathematical Psychology, 2016
- Constraining Cognitive Abstractions Through Bayesian Modeling2015
- Decoding the Brain’s Algorithm for Categorization from Its Neural ImplementationCurrent Biology, 2013
- Classical and Bayesian Inference in Neuroimaging: TheoryNeuroImage, 2002
- Type S error rates for classical and Bayesian single and multiple comparison proceduresComputational Statistics, 2000