Popular Moderation Versus Governmental Authoritarianism: An Interactionist View of Public Sentiments Toward Criminal Sanctions
Authors:
- Douglas R. ThomsonDTDouglas R. Thomson
- Anthony J. RagonaARAnthony J. Ragona
- 1 July 1987
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Crime & Delinquency
- Vol. 33 (3) , 337-357
Abstract
Public opinion polls consistently highlight discontent with criminal court sentencing practices. Generally, respondents find courts to be too lenient. Although these findings are often used in political arguments as evidence of a cogent public desire for harsher sentencing, the conclusion is suspect. Since such surveys generally do not ask respondents to consider contingencies such as offense circumstances, behavioral content of various sentences, or fiscal cost differentials, conventional assessments of public attitudes toward sentencing are deficient in two respects. First, they do not simulate the decision-making task facing judges. Second, they do not allow citizens to consider the relative fiscal costs of current and alternative sentencing practices. By incorporating these two elements, the present study approximates an interactionist approach to the issue of public sentiments toward criminal sanctions. A probability sample survey of 816 Illinois adult residents reveals that, on several dimensions, the public is less vengeful than typically portrayed in public opinion poll and media accounts. Central findings concern public preferences for the sentencing of convicted residential burglars. In particular, there is a strong preference for community sentences, yet a desire for a sanction stronger than straight probation. Such findings are noteworthy given the policy context of recent mandatory incarceration legislation for this offense. Thus this study provides evidence of a previously unremarked phenomenon of legislative sanction escalation far exceeding public preferences.Keywords
This publication has 19 references indexed in Scilit:
- Public Opinion and Prison Policy: A ReviewThe Prison Journal, 1984
- Contending Theories of Criminal Law: Statutory Penalties Versus Public PreferencesJournal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 1982
- Crime, Crime News, and Crime ViewsPublic Opinion Quarterly, 1981
- Public vs. elite opinion on correctional reform: Implications for social policyJournal of Criminal Justice, 1980
- Social Consensus on Norms of Justice: Should the Punishment Fit the Crime?American Journal of Sociology, 1980
- On the Perceived Severity of Legal PenaltiesThe Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology (1973-), 1979
- Public Responses to Hypothetical Crimes: Effect of Offender and Victim Status and Seriousness of the Offense on Punitive ReactionsSocial Forces, 1975
- Crime and Punishment: A Study in Social AttitudesSocial Forces, 1969
- Does the Punishment Fit the Crime? A Study in Social ValuationAmerican Journal of Sociology, 1955
- Crime News in Colorado NewspapersAmerican Journal of Sociology, 1952