The Real Problem with Equipoise
Author:
- 1 August 2006
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The American Journal of Bioethics
- Vol. 6 (4) , 37-47
Abstract
The equipoise requirement in clinical research demands that, if patients are to be randomly assigned to one of two interventions in a clinical trial, there must be genuine doubt about which is better. This reflects the traditional view that physicians must never knowingly compromise the care of their patients, even for the sake of future patients. Equipoise has proven to be deeply problematic, especially in the Third World. Some recent critics have argued against equipoise on the grounds that clinical research is fundamentally distinct from clinical care, and thus should be governed by different norms. I argue against this “difference position,” and instead take issue with the traditional, exclusively patient-centered account of physicians' obligations that equipoise presupposes. In place of this traditional view, I propose a Kantian test for the reasonable partiality that physicians should show their patients, focusing on its application in clinical research and medical education.Keywords
This publication has 17 references indexed in Scilit:
- Justice and the Human Development Approach to International ResearchHastings Center Report, 2005
- Research ethics and evidence based medicine: Table 1Journal of Medical Ethics, 2004
- Sham Surgery and Genuine Standards of Care: Can the Two be Reconciled?The American Journal of Bioethics, 2003
- The Integral Role of Clinical Research in Clinical CareNew England Journal of Medicine, 2003
- Equipose and International Human‐Subjects ResearchBioethics, 2001
- A Trial of Shortened Zidovudine Regimens to Prevent Mother-to-Child Transmission of Human Immunodeficiency Virus Type 1New England Journal of Medicine, 2000
- The Ethics of Clinical Research in the Third WorldNew England Journal of Medicine, 1997
- Should Ethics be More Impersonal? a Critical Notice of Derek Parfit, Reasons and PersonsPhilosophical Review, 1989
- Equipoise and the Ethics of Clinical ResearchNew England Journal of Medicine, 1987
- Medical Ethics and Controlled TrialsBMJ, 1963