Combining Systems and Teamwork Approaches to Enhance the Effectiveness of Safety Improvement Interventions in Surgery
Authors:
- Peter McCullochPMPeter McCulloch
- Lauren MorganLMLauren Morgan
- Ken CatchpoleKCKen Catchpole
- Eleanor RoberstonEREleanor Roberston
- Mohammed HadiMHMohammed Hadi
- Sharon PickeringSPSharon Pickering
- Gary CollinsGCGary Collins
- Damian GriffinDGDamian Griffin
- 1 January 2017
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Annals of Surgery
- Vol. 265 (1) , 90-96
Abstract
IMPORTANCE Patient safety improvement interventions usually address either work systems or team culture. We do not know which is more effective, or whether combining approaches is beneficial. OBJECTIVE To compare improvement in surgical team performance after interventions addressing teamwork culture, work systems, or both. DESIGN Suite of 5 identical controlled before-after intervention studies, with preplanned analysis of pooled data for indirect comparisons of strategies. SETTING Operating theatres in 5 UK hospitals performing elective orthopedic, plastic, or vascular surgery PARTICIPANTS:: All operating theatres staff, including surgeons, nurses, anaesthetists, and others INTERVENTIONS:: 4-month safety improvement interventions, using teamwork training (TT), systems redesign and standardization (SOP), Lean quality improvement, SOP + TT combination, or Lean + TT combination. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES Team technical and nontechnical performance and World Health Organization (WHO) checklist compliance, measured for 3 months before and after intervention using validated scales. Pooled data analysis of before-after change in active and control groups, comparing combined versus single and systems versus teamwork interventions, using 2-way ANOVA. RESULTS We studied 453 operations, (255 intervention, 198 control). TT improved nontechnical skills and WHO compliance (P < 0.001), but not technical performance; systems interventions (Lean & SOP, 2 & 3) improved nontechnical skills and technical performance (P < 0.001) but improved WHO compliance less. Combined interventions (4 & 5) improved all performance measures except WHO time-out attempts, whereas single approaches (1 & 2 & 3) improved WHO compliance less (P < 0.001) and failed to improve technical performance. CONCLUSIONS & RELEVANCE Safety interventions combining teamwork training and systems rationalization are more effective than those adopting either approach alone. This has important implications for safety improvement strategies in hospitals.Keywords
This publication has 31 references indexed in Scilit:
- Promoting a Culture of Safety as a Patient Safety StrategyAnnals of Internal Medicine, 2013
- ‘Matching Michigan’: a 2-year stepped interventional programme to minimise central venous catheter-blood stream infections in intensive care units in EnglandBMJ Quality & Safety, 2012
- A three-dimensional model of error and safety in surgical health care microsystems. Rationale, development and initial testingBMC Surgery, 2011
- Interventions to improve teamwork and communications among healthcare staffBritish Journal of Surgery, 2011
- Multiple component patient safety intervention in English hospitals: controlled evaluation of second phaseBMJ, 2011
- Effect of a Comprehensive Surgical Safety System on Patient OutcomesNew England Journal of Medicine, 2010
- Healthcare processes must be improved to reduce the occurrence of orthopaedic adverse eventsScandinavian Journal of Caring Sciences, 2010
- Quality and Safety on an Acute Surgical WardAnnals of Surgery, 2009
- Improving patient safety in intensive care units in MichiganJournal of Critical Care, 2008
- Communication failures in the operating room: an observational classification of recurrent types and effectsQuality and Safety in Health Care, 2004