Abstract
Generative AI raises short-term productivity by completing tasks that learners would otherwise practice on their own. Whether this exchange erodes frontier skill, the capability required for top-tail performance without AI, depends on the mode of use: substitute-users let AI stand in for deliberate practice and fail to develop skill, while complement-users use it to accelerate skill development. For institutions that train and certify talent, the design question is therefore not whether to allow AI but how to govern the mode of its use. We study one governance mechanism, the AI-prohibited evaluation gate, and ask whether it can separate the two modes. Elite competitive programming provides a test case. The International Collegiate Programming Contest (ICPC) and the International Olympiad in Informatics (IOI) prohibit AI under in-person proctoring and admit entrants through qualification rounds, whereas online Codeforces (CF) practice is unproctored and open to all. From CF submission histories we build an AI-prompt signature, marked by more first-attempt acceptances and fewer attempts and debugging retries, consistent with AI-assisted practice. Three findings follow. CF practice has shifted toward this signature across entry cohorts spanning two AI rollouts. In open CF contests, a stronger signature predicts smaller rating gains for users with no ICPC or IOI affiliation, but not for users who qualified for the AI-prohibited contests. Inside the AI-prohibited ICPC environment, a shift toward AI-style practice predicts higher non-AI-aided scores for AI-era entrants. The same AI-prompt signature carries opposite signs depending on whether the contest screens its entrants through an AI-prohibited qualification gate, exactly the pattern a type-separating gate predicts. The message is constructive: AI-style practice is compatible with frontier skill; the skill erosion risk links to the substitute mode of use; and that mode is separable by the kind of gates already standard at credential boundaries, from medical and legal boards to professional certification.