Accuracy and completeness of publication and citation records in the Web of Science, PsycINFO, and Google Scholar: A case study for the computation of h indices in Psychology
- 15 September 2010
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology
- Vol. 61 (10) , 2070-2085
Abstract
Hirsch's h index is becoming the standard measure of an individual's research accomplishments. The aggregation of individuals' measures is also the basis for global measures at institutional or national levels. To investigate whether the h index can be reliably computed through alternative sources of citation records, the Web of Science (WoS), PsycINFO and Google Scholar (GS) were used to collect citation records for known publications of four Spanish psychologists. Compared with WoS, PsycINFO included a larger percentage of publication records, whereas GS outperformed WoS and PsycINFO in this respect. Compared with WoS, PsycINFO retrieved a larger number of citations in unique areas of psychology, but it retrieved a smaller number of citations in areas that are close to statistics or the neurosciences, whereas GS retrieved the largest numbers of citations in all cases. Incorrect citations were scarce in Wos (0.3%), more prevalent in PsycINFO (1.1%), and overwhelming in GS (16.5%). All platforms retrieved unique citations, the largest set coming from GS. WoS and PsycINFO cover distinct areas of psychology unevenly, thus applying different penalties on the h index of researches working in different fields. Obtaining fair and accurate h indices required the union of citations retrieved by all three platforms.Keywords
This publication has 94 references indexed in Scilit:
- The state of h index researchEMBO Reports, 2008
- The Misused Impact FactorScience, 2008
- Playing the system to give low-impact journal more cloutNature, 2008
- Escape from the impact factorEthics in Science and Environmental Politics, 2008
- Data sources for performing citation analysis: an overviewJournal of Documentation, 2008
- Is the impact of journal impact factors decreasing?Journal of Documentation, 2008
- Irreproducible results: a response to Thomson ScientificJournal of Cell Biology, 2008
- Comparing test searches in PubMed and Google ScholarJournal of the Medical Library Association, 2007
- The mismeasurement of scienceCurrent Biology, 2007
- The Impact Factor GamePLOS Medicine, 2006