Algorithmic Profiling and Facial Recognition in EU Border Control: Examining ETIAS Decision‐Making, Privacy and Law
- 11 April 2025
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in WIREs Data Mining and Knowledge Discovery
- Vol. 15 (2)
Abstract
The growing use of algorithmic and biometric technologies in border control is part of a larger trend in global security governance that has significant legal and ethical implications for their effect on individual rights and procedural justice. As central features in the EU's shifting security regime, ETIAS and facial recognition technologies deploy algorithmic profiling and biometric risk assessment to screen visa‐exempt third‐country nationals. The research systematically examines the decision‐making processes of ETIAS and the overall facial recognition system, demonstrating the interplay between algorithmic risk assessments and discretionary human discretion by national authorities. It contends that the algorithmic profiling lack of transparency, combined with sweeping national security exceptions, produces a procedural void, in which the right to reasoned decisions and effective remedies is compromised. Second, the use of interoperable databases and risk indicators puts core data protection principles into jeopardy, notably purpose limitation and the right to be forgotten. This paper also argues that ETIAS and the application of facial recognition technologies represent a larger trend toward “techno‐regulatory assemblages” in EU governance, where technological infrastructures increasingly influence legal and administrative decisions. It critically assesses whether the human oversight mechanisms incorporated within ETIAS National Units are adequate to prevent the risks involved in automated decision‐making, especially in the face of strict time pressures and security requirements. The study detects a latent paradox: though these systems aim to strengthen a “Security Union,” they might inadvertently lead to an “Insecurity Union” by undermining transparency, procedural protections, and citizen rights.Keywords
This publication has 14 references indexed in Scilit:
- Countermeasures against bias and spoofing in modern facial recognition systemsWorld Journal of Advanced Research and Reviews, 2025
- Integrated cybersecurity for metaverse systems operating with artificial intelligence, blockchains, and cloud computingFrontiers in Blockchain, 2024
- When Is a Decision Automated? A Taxonomy for a Fundamental Rights AnalysisGerman Law Journal, 2024
- Rule of Law Challenges of ‘Algorithmic Discretion’ & Automation in EU Border ControlEuropean Journal of Migration and Law, 2023
- Datafication Genealogies beyond Algorithmic Fairness: Making Up Racialised Subjects2023
- A Survey on Metaverse: Fundamentals, Security, and PrivacyIEEE Communications Surveys & Tutorials, 2022
- Neither opaque nor transparent: A transdisciplinary methodology to investigate datafication at the EU bordersBig Data & Society, 2022
- Mapping the Use of Facial Recognition in Public Spaces in Europe – Part 3: Facial Recognition for Authorisation PurposesSSRN Electronic Journal, 2022
- Argus: A centralized control system for preserving privacy during digital forensics investigationsWIREs Forensic Science, 2021
- Data mining privacy preserving: Research agendaWIREs Data Mining and Knowledge Discovery, 2020