A Comparison of Student Behavioral Engagement in Traditional Live Coding and Active Live Coding Lectures
Open Access
- 3 July 2024
- conference paper
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM)
- p. 513-519
Abstract
Live coding is a recommended teaching practice in which an instructor dynamically programs in front of students. However, findings related to students' engagement during live coding are mixed. Some works have reported that live codingseems to improve student engagement while others regard live coding as an activity in which students passively observe the instructor without asking questions or following along. Active live coding, in which students extend a live coding example and discuss with peers, incorporates active learning with the traditional live coding approach. We conducted a quasi-experimental study in which one section of an advanced introductory programming course was taught using active live coding (ALC) and the other was taught using traditional live coding (TLC). The goal of this work is to compare students' behavioral engagement in the two lectures using a classroom observation protocol called the Behavioral Engagement Related to Instruction (BERI) protocol. Our results from the 2,790 observations we collected indicate that traditional live coding engages only 65% of students, on average. However, we found a "persisting engagement'' effect of active live coding, where students were significantlymore engaged in the traditional live coding components of a lecture up to 20 minutesafter the active live coding component. Notably, the two lecture groups performed similarly on the Post-Lecture Questions, which were administered after each lecture as a review of the lecture material. Therefore, our results indicate an improved student engagement due to active live coding, but do not show a corresponding improvement in conceptual knowledge.Keywords
Funding Information
- National Science Foundation (2044473)
This publication has 24 references indexed in Scilit:
- Live Coding: A Review of the Literature2021
- Live-coding vs Static Code Examples2020
- Coding Demonstration Videos for CS12019
- Role of Live-coding in Learning Introductory Programming2018
- Lightweight, Early Identification of At-Risk CS1 Students2016
- Illustrating performance indicators and course characteristics to support students’ self-regulated learning in CS1Computer Science Education, 2015
- The effectiveness of live-coding to teach introductory programming2013
- Halving fail rates using peer instruction2013
- Peer instruction2011
- Restoring "coding with intention" in introductory programming courses2007