Trauma & TYPOI: The Fourth Gospel as Warning Not Example
Open Access
Abstract
There are at least four traumatic events that likely lie behind the Gospel of John: (1) Jesus’ death and inaccessibility, (2) the destruction of the Jerusalem Temple, (3) the Johannine community’s excommunication from the synagogue, and (4) the loss of the Beloved Disciple. Evidence of all of these traumas can be found in the Gospel itself and, as extant, the Gospel exhibits a number of strategies for addressing these experiences of suffering. Working from Gaston Bachelard’s observations regarding literature produced in response to suffering, this paper outlines the textual evidence for each of these experiences of suffering, notes the responses to them that the Gospel displays, and seeks briefly to evaluate the responses for the TYPOI (patterns/examples/warnings) they provide. In short, the Fourth Gospel employs psychologically attractive, compensatory responses to experiences of loss. However, it deploys in parallel a toxic cocktail of anti-Jewish polemic, condemnation of “the world”, and self-protective, sectarian insularity. Regarding whether the text’s trauma response can be viewed as exemplary for ethically-minded Christians, Desmond Tutu’s 2009 statement, “there are certain parts [of the Bible] which you have to say no to”, is directly applicable, while the warning the text’s example suggests is significant.Keywords
This publication has 43 references indexed in Scilit:
- Incarnation and Covenant: The Fourth Gospel through the Lens of Trauma TheoryInterpretation: A Journal of Bible and Theology, 2014
- Social theory and traumaActa Sociologica, 2013
- 4 Aposynagōgos and Empire2013
- Bringing the Academic Discipline of Psychology to Bear on the Study of the BibleThe Journal of Theological Studies, 2012
- Expanding Trauma through Space and Time: Mapping the Rhetorical Strategies of Trauma Carrier GroupsSocial Psychology Quarterly, 2009
- Birkat Ha-MinimRevisitedNew Testament Studies, 2009
- Left Behind: Jesus' Consolation of His Disciples in John 13,31–17,26Zeitschrift für die neutestamentliche Wissenschaft, 2005
- On Traumatic Knowledge and Literary StudiesNew Literary History, 1995
- Of Other Spacesdiacritics, 1986
- The Man from Heaven in Johannine SectarianismJournal of Biblical Literature, 1972