A meta‐analysis comparing efficacy and safety between proton beam therapy versus carbon ion radiotherapy
Open Access
- 23 February 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Cancer Medicine
- Vol. 13 (3) , e7023
Abstract
Background: This study aimed to compare the outcomes of proton beam therapy (PBT) and carbon ion radiotherapy (CIRT) by a systematic review and meta‐analysis of the existing clinical evidence.Methods: A systematic literature search was performed to identify studies comparing the clinical outcomes of PBT and CIRT. The included studies were required to report oncological outcomes (local control [LC], progression‐free survival [PFS], or overall survival [OS]) or adverse events.Results: Eighteen articles comprising 1857 patients (947 treated with PBT and 910 treated with CIRT) were included in the analysis. The pooled analysis conducted for the overall population yielded average hazard ratios of 0.690 (95% confidence interval (CI), 0.493–0.967, p = 0.031) for LC, 0.952 (95% CI, 0.604–1.500, p = 0.590) for PFS, and 1.183 (0.872–1.607, p = 0.281) for OS with reference to CIRT. The subgroup analyses included patients treated in the head and neck, areas other than the head and neck, and patients with chordomas and chondrosarcomas. These analyses revealed no significant differences in most outcomes, except for LC in the subgroup of patients treated in areas other than the head and neck. Adverse event rates were comparable in both groups, with an odds ratio (OR) of 1.097 (95% CI, 0.744–1.616, p = 0.641). Meta‐regression analysis for possible heterogeneity did not demonstrate a significant association between treatment outcomes and the ratio of biologically effective doses between modalities.Conclusion: This study highlighted the comparability of PBT and CIRT in terms of oncological outcomes and adverse events.Keywords
This publication has 44 references indexed in Scilit:
- High‐dose proton therapy and carbon‐ion therapy for stage I nonsmall cell lung cancerCancer, 2010
- Proton vs carbon ion beams in the definitive radiation treatment of cancer patientsRadiotherapy and Oncology, 2010
- Comparison of the effectiveness of radiotherapy with photons, protons and carbon-ions for non-small cell lung cancer: A meta-analysisRadiotherapy and Oncology, 2010
- Biological characteristics of carbon-ion therapyInternational Journal of Radiation Biology, 2009
- Practical methods for incorporating summary time-to-event data into meta-analysisTrials, 2007
- Particle Radiation Therapy Using Proton and Heavier Ion BeamsJournal of Clinical Oncology, 2007
- Examination of GyE system for HIMAC carbon therapyInternational Journal of Radiation Oncology - Biology - Physics (IJROBP), 2006
- The centenary of the discovery of the Bragg peakRadiotherapy and Oncology, 2004
- Extracting summary statistics to perform meta-analyses of the published literature for survival endpointsStatistics in Medicine, 1998
- Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical testBMJ, 1997