Epistemic disagreement in psychopathology research and practice: A procedural model
Open Access
- 25 July 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Theory & Psychology
- Vol. 34 (4) , 484-507
Abstract
Clinical psychology is characterized by persistent disagreement about fundamental aspects of the discipline ranging from what mental disorders are to what constitutes effective treatment. Attempts to address the problem of epistemic disagreement have been frequently based on establishing the correct answer by fiat without identifying and addressing the sources of the disagreement. We argue that this strategy has not worked very well and the result is frequently ongoing and intractable disagreement, with each side in an argument convinced they are correct. In this paper, we outline an epistemic disagreement procedural model intended to assist researchers and clinicians in the field of clinical psychology to identify, explore, and develop inquiry strategies that capitalize on situations where competing knowledge claims are made. The result is a flexible conceptual framework committed to a defensible epistemic pluralism, fallibilism, and contextualism, across the various research tasks constituting the field of clinical psychology.Keywords
This publication has 46 references indexed in Scilit:
- Embodied, Embedded, and Enactive Psychopathology2023
- Realism for Realistic People2022
- The Epistemic Benefits of Disagreement2020
- Cognitive Errors and Diagnostic Mistakes2019
- A network theory of mental disordersWorld Psychiatry, 2017
- Medical Theory and Its Notions of Definition and Explanation2017
- Giving up on convergence and autonomy: Why the theories of psychology and neuroscience are codependent as well as irreconcilableStudies in History and Philosophy of Science, 2016
- The value of epistemic disagreement in scientific practice. The case of Homo floresiensisStudies in History and Philosophy of Science, 2013
- Dopamine and reward: The anhedonia hypothesis 30 years onNeurotoxicity Research, 2008
- Informal Logic2001