Should We Measure Professionalism with an Index? A Note on Theory and Practice in State Legislative Professionalism Research
- 1 September 2014
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in State Politics & Policy Quarterly
- Vol. 14 (3) , 277-296
Abstract
Legislative professionalism has played a prominent role in state politics research for decades. Despite the attention paid to its causes and consequences, recent research has largely set aside questions about professionalism's conceptualization and operationalization. Usually measuring it as an aggregate index, scholars theoretically and empirically treat professionalism as a unidimensional concept. In this article, we argue that exclusive use of aggregate indices can limit state politics research. Using a new dataset with almost 40 years of data on state legislative resources, salary, and session length, we reconsider the validity of using an index to study professionalism across the states. We evaluate the internal consistency of professionalism components over time, the relationship between components and the Squire Index, and the degree to which professionalism components are unidimensional using classical multidimensional scaling. We find enough commonality and enough variation between professionalism components to support a range of measurement strategies like the use of unidimensional indices (such as the Squire Index), disaggregating the components and analyzing their effects individually, or formulating multidimensional measures. Scholars should take care to choose the appropriate measure of the concept that best fits the causal relationships under examination.Keywords
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- Broad Bills or Particularistic Policy? Historical Patterns in American State LegislaturesAmerican Political Science Review, 2010
- Who Blinks First? Legislative Patience and Bargaining with GovernorsLegislative Studies Quarterly, 2009
- Legislative Professionalism and Influence on State Agencies: The Effects of Resources and CareerismLegislative Studies Quarterly, 2006
- Government Growth and Professionalism in U.S. State LegislaturesLegislative Studies Quarterly, 2006
- Changes in Professionalism in U. S. State LegislaturesLegislative Studies Quarterly, 2000
- Citizens, Structures, and Sister States: Influences on State Legislative ProfessionalismLegislative Studies Quarterly, 1995
- Professionalization and Public Opinion of State LegislaturesThe Journal of Politics, 1993
- Dimensions of State Government CapabilityThe Western Political Quarterly, 1988
- Dimensions of State Government CapabilityThe Western Political Quarterly, 1988
- Coefficient Alpha and the Internal Structure of TestsPsychometrika, 1951