Persuasive Definitions and Public Policy Arguments
Author:
- Douglas WaltonDWDouglas Walton
- 1 January 2001
- journal article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Argumentation and Advocacy
- Vol. 37 (3) , 117-132
Abstract
This paper shows how persuasive definitions are extremely powerful rhetorical tools often used to influence public policy arguments. In five case studies analyzed and evaluated, the use of the persuasive definition as an argumentative technique had consequences that changed social policies in a way that led to significant gains in the interests of some advocacy groups and losses in the interests of other advocacy groups. Several hypotheses are put forward concerning the conditions under which the use of a persuasive definition ought to bejudged appropriate or not in a given case. A new dialectical approach to the study of definitions is proposed.Keywords
This publication has 7 references indexed in Scilit:
- An Ideological Basis for Definition in Public Argument: A Case Study of the Individuals with Disabilities in Education ActArgumentation and Advocacy, 1999
- The New Dialectic1998
- Rape and Persuasive DefinitionCanadian Journal of Philosophy, 1995
- Arguing about definitionsArgumentation, 1993
- Reagan's safety net for the truly needy: The rhetorical uses of definitionCentral States Speech Journal, 1984
- Stipulated definitions and elementary logicCentral States Speech Journal, 1973
- IV.—PERSUASIVE DEFINITIONSMind, 1938