Genetic screening and democracy: lessons from debating genetic screening criteria in the Netherlands
Open Access
- 30 August 2011
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Community Genetics
- Vol. 3 (2) , 79-89
Abstract
Recent decades have witnessed increasing possibilities for genetic testing and screening. In clinical genetics, the doctor’s office defined a secluded space for discussion of sensitive reproductive options in cases of elevated risk for genetic disorders in individuals or their offspring. When prenatal screening for all pregnant women became conceivable, the potential increase in scale made social and ethical concerns relevant for the whole of society. Whereas genetic testing in clinical genetic practice was widely accepted, prenatal screening at a population level met with unease. Concerns were raised regarding social pressure to screen: the sum of individual choice might result in a ‘collective eugenics’. The government’s involvement also raised suspicion: actively offering screening evoked associations with eugenic population policies from the first half of the 20th century. By reconstructing elements of policy and public debate on prenatal screening in the Netherlands from the past 30 years, this article discusses how the government has gradually changed its role in balancing the interest of the individual and the collective on genetic reproductive issues. Against a background of increasing knowledge about and demand for prenatal screening among the population, governmental policy changed from focusing on protection by banning screening toward facilitating screening in a careful and ethically sound way by providing adequate information, decision aids and quality assessment instruments. In the meanwhile, invigorating democracy in public debate may entail discussing concepts of ‘the good life’ in relation to living with or without impairments and dealing with genetic information about oneself or one’s offspring.Keywords
This publication has 14 references indexed in Scilit:
- Get ready for the flood of fetal gene screeningNature, 2011
- Non-invasive prenatal assessment of trisomy 21 by multiplexed maternal plasma DNA sequencing: large scale validity studyBMJ, 2011
- Maternal Plasma DNA Sequencing Reveals the Genome-Wide Genetic and Mutational Profile of the FetusScience Translational Medicine, 2010
- In Principle Method for Noninvasive Determination of the Fetal GenomeNature Precedings, 2010
- Where are you going, where have you been: a recent history of the direct-to-consumer genetic testing marketJournal of Community Genetics, 2010
- Non-invasive prenatal testing: ethical issues exploredEuropean Journal of Human Genetics, 2009
- Storytelling to Enrich the Democratic Debate: The Dutch Discussion on Embryo Selection for Hereditary Breast CancerBioSocieties, 2009
- A generic tool for development of decision aids based on clinical practice guidelinesPatient Education and Counseling, 2008
- Accepting or declining the offer of prenatal screening for congenital defects: test uptake and women's reasonsPrenatal Diagnosis, 2005
- Community genetics in the Netherlands2000