Estimation of benchmark dose ratio distributions for subchronic-to-chronic extrapolation using meta-analysis
- 25 August 2025
- journal article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Toxicological Sciences
- Vol. 208 (1) , 167-175
Abstract
Recently, the International Programme on Chemical Safety (IPCS) developed a unified probabilistic framework for deriving reference values and a software tool, Approximate Probabilistic Analysis (APROBA), to help implement this framework. The distributions of multiple sources of uncertainty and variability were estimated, including uncertainty when extrapolating from subchronic to chronic data. The subchronic-to-chronic distribution was estimated using ratios between subchronic and chronic benchmark doses (BMDs) and was determined to be approximately lognormal, with parameter values reported by IPCS. These parameters were estimated largely from historical data on body and organ weights from toxicological studies. We estimated the distribution using a larger collection of data, including histopathological and clinical endpoints. Our analysis determined that key assumptions of the method and the default values in APROBA are consistent with the results from the new data. However, the uncertainty of predictions for dichotomous response data was greater than assumed in APROBA, and the reference values derived using our new results were lower than those derived from APROBA (by 25% in an example case). Also, APROBA's default parameter values do not account fully for the uncertainty of predicted chronic BMDs. Most importantly, the uncertainty of the prediction can be much greater than assumed in APROBA if BMDs are accepted when they fall well outside the observed dose range or when an upper confidence limit is not quantifiable. Careful evaluation of dose–response model fit, including a number of indicators of model suitability in addition to standard goodness-of-fit statistics, is necessary to improve quantification of uncertainty.Keywords
This publication has 12 references indexed in Scilit:
- Python BMDS: A Python interface library and web application for the canonical EPA dose-response modeling softwareReproductive Toxicology, 2019
- ToxRefDB version 2.0: Improved utility for predictive and retrospective toxicology analysesReproductive Toxicology, 2019
- A Unified Probabilistic Framework for Dose–Response Assessment of Human Health EffectsEnvironmental Health Perspectives, 2015
- Methods to estimate the between‐study variance and its uncertainty in meta‐analysisResearch Synthesis Methods, 2015
- The Impact of Levene’s Test of Equality of Variances on Statistical Theory and PracticeStatistical Science, 2009
- Statistical Meta‐Analysis with Applications2008
- Deriving a Data-Based Interspecies Assessment Factor Using the NOAEL and the Benchmark Dose ApproachCritical Reviews in Toxicology, 2007
- A Comparison of Ratio Distributions Based on the NOAEL and the Benchmark Approach for Subchronic-to-Chronic ExtrapolationToxicological Sciences, 2005
- Evaluation of the Uncertainty Factor for Subchronic-to-Chronic Extrapolation: Statistical Analysis of Toxicity DataRegulatory Toxicology and Pharmacology, 1998
- A new approach to deriving community exposure guidelines from “no-observed-adverse-effect levels”Regulatory Toxicology and Pharmacology, 1990