Future proofing the principle of no significant harm
Authors:
Open Access
- 2 November 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in International Environmental Agreements: Politics, Law and Economics
- Vol. 20 (4) , 731-747
Abstract
The principle of ‘no significant harm’ as a way of addressing transboundary environmental challenges is both inadequately researched and inadequately implemented in many parts of the world. This paper addresses the questions: What is the nature of transboundary harm in the Anthropocene? Is the principle of no significant harm able to address current and pre-empt future transboundary harm in the field of water and environmental law? This special issue has focused on this principle in the arena of water law. This article integrates the findings in the context of a broader understanding of global harm in the Anthropocene. We draw 4 conclusions. First, conceptually harm is moving beyond direct inter-state harm between neighbouring countries to a multi-directional, multi-actor/multi-level harm, which is increasingly creeping and cumulative, with growing spatial and temporal characteristics. It thus requires moving beyond quibbling over what is ‘significant’ harm to recognize the climate emergency, the sixth biodiversity extinction, the huge damage to water systems and to realize that the threshold of ecosystem and human tolerance of damage are reducing rapidly. Second, however, the no-harm principle tends to be better developed in qualifying sovereignty in relation to transboundary harm on rivers than in the broader environmental and development arena as demonstrated by agenda 2030 which reverts to full permanent sovereignty. Third, legal scholarship, however, does provide a wide range of instruments for addressing harm before it occurs, after it has happened, and considering the differentiated economic capacity of the actors. Finally, the larger problem is that it is not individual projects or programmes that cause problems as much as national prioritization of economic growth which has led to externalizing the environment. The no-harm principle will be ineffective if it cannot be used to question the content of ‘growth’-led policies. There is need to future proof the no-harm principle.Keywords
Funding Information
- University of Amsterdam
This publication has 37 references indexed in Scilit:
- State Responsibility and Climate Change Governance: A Light through the StormChinese Journal of International Law, 2014
- Inside the System, Outside the Box: Palau’s Pursuit of Climate Justice and Security at the United NationsTransnational Environmental Law, 2014
- Downstream riparians can also harm upstream riparians: the concept of foreclosure of future usesWater International, 2010
- State Responsibility for Climate Change DamagesNordic Journal of International Law, 2008
- The Precautionary Principle in General International Law: Combating the Babylonian ConfusionReview of European Community & International Environmental Law, 2007
- Can there be science-based precaution?Environmental Research Letters, 2006
- The ILC Draft Principles on the Allocation of Loss in the Case of Transboundary Harm Arising out of Hazardous Activities: Privatizing Risk?Review of European Community & International Environmental Law, 2005
- Increasing Participation and Compliance in International Climate Change AgreementsInternational Environmental Agreements: Politics, Law and Economics, 2003
- The Myth and Reality of Transboundary Environmental Impact AssessmentAmerican Journal of International Law, 2002
- Worlds Apart? The Reception of Genetically Modified Foods in Europe and the U.S.Science, 1999