Teaching ethics in engineering education through historical analysis
- 1 June 2006
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Science and Engineering Ethics
- Vol. 12 (2) , 205-222
Abstract
The goal of this paper is to stress the significance of ethics for engineering education and to illustrate how it can be brought into the mainstream of higher education in a natural way that is integrated with the teaching objectives of enriching the core meaning of engineering. Everyone will agree that the practicing engineer should be virtuous, should be a good colleague, and should use professional understanding for the common good. But these injunctions to virtue do not reach closely enough the ethic of the engineer as engineer, as someone acting in a uniquely engineering situation, and it is to such conditions that I wish to speak through a set of specific examples from recent history. I shall briefly refer to four controversies between engineers. Then, in some detail I shall narrate three historical cases that directly involve the actions of one engineer, and finally I would like to address some common contemporary issues. The first section, “Engineering Ethics and the History of Innovation” includes four cases involving professional controversy. Each controversy sets two people against each other in disputes over who invented the telegraph, the radio, the automobile, and the airplane. In each dispute, it is possible to identify ethical and unethical behavior or ambiguous ethical behavior that serves as a basis for educational discussion. The first two historical cases described in “Crises and the Engineer” involve the primary closure dam systems in the Netherlands, each one the result of the actions of one engineer. The third tells of an American engineer who took his political boss, a big city mayor, to court over the illegal use of a watershed. The challenges these engineers faced required, in the deepest sense, a commitment to ethical behavior that is unique to engineering and instructive to our students. Finally, the cases in “Professors and Comparative Critical Analysis” illuminate the behavior of engineers in the design of structures and also how professors can make public criticisms of designs that seem wasteful.Keywords
This publication has 6 references indexed in Scilit:
- Engineering Ethical Curricula: Assessment and Comparison of Two ApproachesJournal of Engineering Education, 2005
- The dilemma of ethics in engineering educationScience and Engineering Ethics, 2004
- The New Art of Structural Engineering: An Introductory Course in StructuresStructural Engineering International, 1994
- Robert Maillart's Bridges1979
- History and Esthetics in Suspension BridgesJournal of the Structural Division, 1977
- Art in Engineering — The Need for a New CriticismEngineering Issues: Journal of Professional Activities, 1973