Systematic review of international Delphi surveys for core outcome set development: representation of international patients
Open Access
Abstract
Objectives A core outcome set (COS) describes a minimum set of outcomes to be reported by all clinical trials of one healthcare condition. Delphi surveys are frequently used to achieve consensus on core outcomes. International input is important to achieve global COS uptake. We aimed to investigate participant representation in international Delphi surveys, with reference to the inclusion of patients and participants from low and middle income countries as stakeholders (LMICs). Design Systematic review. Data sources EMBASE, Medline, Web of Science, COMET database and hand-searching. Eligibility criteria Protocols and studies describing Delphi surveys used to develop an international COS for trial reporting, published between 1 January 2017 and 6 June 2019. Data extraction and synthesis Delphi participants were grouped as patients or healthcare professionals (HCPs). Participants were considered international if their country of origin was different to that of the first or senior author. Data extraction included participant numbers, country of origin, country income group and whether Delphi surveys were translated. We analysed the impact these factors had on outcome prioritisation. Results Of 90 included studies, 69% (n=62) were completed and 31% (n=28) were protocols. Studies recruited more HCPs than patients (median 60 (IQR 30–113) vs 30 (IQR 14–66) participants, respectively). A higher percentage of HCPs was international compared with patients (57% (IQR 37–78) vs 20% (IQR 0–68)). Only 31% (n=28) studies recruited participants from LMICs. Regarding recruitment from LMICs, patients were under-represented (16% studies; n=8) compared with HCPs (22%; n=28). Few (7%; n=6) studies translated Delphi surveys. Only 3% studies (n=3) analysed Delphi responses by geographical location; all found differences in outcome prioritisation. Conclusions There is a disproportionately lower inclusion of international patients, compared with HCPs, in COS-development Delphi surveys, particularly within LMICs. Future international Delphi surveys should consider exploring for geographical and income-based differences in outcome prioritisation. PROSPERO registration number CRD42019138519.Keywords
This publication has 101 references indexed in Scilit:
- A Standard Set of Outcome Measures for the Comprehensive Appraisal of Cleft CareThe Cleft Palate Craniofacial Journal, 2017
- Core Outcome Set–STAndards for Reporting: The COS-STAR StatementPLOS Medicine, 2016
- Low- and middle-income countries face many common barriers to implementation of maternal health evidence productsJournal of Clinical Epidemiology, 2016
- Clinicians’ perspective on key domains in ANCA-associated vasculitis: a Delphi exerciseScandinavian Journal of Rheumatology, 2016
- Which treatment outcomes are most important to aphasia clinicians and managers? An international e-Delphi consensus studyAphasiology, 2016
- Core outcome sets and systematic reviewsSystematic Reviews, 2016
- Developing core outcome sets for clinical trials: issues to considerTrials, 2012
- Improved clinical outcome after invasive management of patients with recent myocardial infarction and proven myocardial viability: primary results of a randomized controlled trial (VIAMI-trial)Trials, 2012
- The PRISMA statement for reporting systematic reviews and meta-analyses of studies that evaluate health care interventions: explanation and elaborationJournal of Clinical Epidemiology, 2009
- Weighted kappa: Nominal scale agreement provision for scaled disagreement or partial credit.Psychological Bulletin, 1968