Ethics of male circumcision in minors: a scoping review of parental authority, adolescent involvement, and implications for sexual medicine practice and policy
- 30 September 2026
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Sexual Medicine Reviews
- Vol. 14 (4)
Abstract
Introduction: Male circumcision in minors remains widely practiced in many regions of the world, although its prevalence varies considerably across cultural, religious, and geographic contexts. Beyond its medical dimensions, circumcision is closely linked to religion, culture, masculinity, family identity, and public health agendas. Ethical debates commonly involve tensions between parental authority, bodily autonomy, assent, and children’s rights, particularly because minors are often minimally involved in decision-making processes. Methods: A scoping review was conducted to examine ethical, sociocultural, legal, and decision-making dimensions related to circumcision in minors. Literature searches were performed across MEDLINE, Web of Science, Scopus, ProQuest, SpringerLink, CINAHL/EBSCO, SAGE, and Taylor & Francis. Thirty-one eligible studies were included and analyzed using narrative and thematic synthesis approaches. Results: Ethical dilemmas surrounding circumcision in minors were found to be highly context-dependent and not ethically interchangeable across all forms of circumcision. Five major contextual typologies were identified: religious circumcision, traditional or rite-of-passage circumcision, therapeutic circumcision, public-health-driven voluntary medical male circumcision (VMMC), and elective or family-preference circumcision. Six major thematic frameworks emerged, including parental authority, constrained adolescent agency, public health versus bodily autonomy, masculinity formation, moral conflict and regret, and healthcare and legal systems as ethical gatekeepers. Circumcision decision-making was shaped by multilayered interactions involving family structures, sociocultural norms, healthcare systems, and public health priorities. Conclusion: Ethical interpretations of circumcision in minors cannot be reduced to a simple binary distinction between ethical and unethical practices. Greater recognition of contextual differences and developmentally appropriate assent may support more ethically responsive and culturally sensitive circumcision practices. Policies and clinical guidelines should avoid applying uniform ethical approaches across all circumcision contexts. More context-sensitive frameworks incorporating assent procedures, adolescent involvement, culturally sensitive counseling, and safeguards against coercion may strengthen ethical governance in circumcision practices involving minors. Trial Registration: This study was registered in the PROSPERO database (CRD420251074798). URL: https://www.crd.york.ac.uk/PROSPERO/view/CRD420251074798. Date of registration: September 26, 2025Keywords
This publication has 47 references indexed in Scilit:
- Parental regret following decision for sons to undergo elective post-neonatal circumcisionJournal of Pediatric Urology, 2024
- Early Infant Male Circumcision Decisions in Zambia: Demographic and Familial InfluencesAIDS and Behavior, 2024
- Consent and Assent in Pediatric ResearchPediatric Clinics of North America, 2023
- Decisional conflict in American parents regarding newborn circumcisionJournal of Pediatric Urology, 2023
- Children’s Rights and Digital Technologies2018
- Nontherapeutic Circumcision of Minors as an Ethically Problematic Form of Iatrogenic InjuryAMA Journal of Ethics, 2017
- Defining the Pathways of Parental Decision-making and Satisfaction Levels About Newborn Circumcision in a Setting Where Traditional Male Circumcision is Prevalent: An Online Survey StudyUrology, 2016
- Factors Associated with Preference for Early Infant Male Circumcision Among a Representative Sample of Parents in Homa Bay County, Western KenyaAIDS and Behavior, 2016
- Can Culture Justify Infant Circumcision?Res Publica, 2014
- Circumcision ControversiesPediatric Clinics of North America, 2012