Significant Silences in Locke'sTwo Treatises of Government: Constitutional History, Contract and Law
Author:
- 1 June 1988
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in The Historical Journal
- Vol. 31 (2) , 275-294
Abstract
It is increasingly common in modern literary theory to read that a text's meaning must be elicited from the textual ‘possibilities which arenot said’. At this level of generality, the proposition applies equally to the interpretation of non-literary as literary texts. In this paper, I shall endeavour to illustrate the usefulness of this approach by considering the meaning of Locke's argument inTwo treatisesin terms of things which Locke chose not to say. I shall argue two points. First, I shall suggest that many of the controversies which have arisen in recent years about Locke's meaning have suffered because inadequate attention has been paid to the precise character of a number of silences in Locke's argument. The persistence of an inadequate framework for understanding the character of Englishmen's appeals to an original contract, constitutional law and history in the late seventeenth century will occupy my attention here. Second, I shall suggest that attention to the details of Locke's most significant silences can cast light on current controversies about the intellectual status of Locke's argument. In particular, I shall argue that the current tendency to locateTwo treatiseswithin a context of coded, conspiratorial politics is mistaken.Keywords
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- ‘Abdicate’ and ‘Contract’ RestoredThe Historical Journal, 1985
- John Locke on the Glorious Revolution: A Rediscovered DocumentThe Historical Journal, 1985
- ‘The Rulers now on Earth’: Locke'sTwo Treatisesand the Revolution of 1688The Historical Journal, 1985
- Virtue, Commerce, and History1985
- Locke, Revolution Principles, and the Formation of Whig IdeologyThe Historical Journal, 1983
- The Glorious Revolution: ‘Contract’ and ‘Abdication’ ReconsideredThe Historical Journal, 1982
- Natural Rights Theories1979
- Revolution Principles1977
- The Goths in England1952
- Die Idee einer Altgermanischen Freiheit vor Montesquieu1925