Assessment of Two Measurement Techniques of Cervical Spine and C1–C2 Rotation in the Outcome Research of Axis Fractures
Authors:
- Heiko KollerHKHeiko Koller
- Herbert ReschHRHerbert Resch
- Frank AcostaFAFrank Acosta
- Juliane ZennerJZJuliane Zenner
- Robert SchwaigerRSRobert Schwaiger
- Mark TauberMTMark Tauber
- Rosemarie ForstnerRFRosemarie Forstner
- Stefan LedererSLStefan Lederer
- Alexander AuffarthAAAlexander Auffarth
- Wolfgang HitzlWolfgang Hitzl
- 1 February 2010
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Spine
- Vol. 35 (3) , 286-290
Abstract
In vivo study on cervical spine motion. To estimate the accuracy of clinical measurements, using a handheld goniometer for the assessment of total cervical neck rotation in outcome research of patients with C2 fractures and particularly odontoid fractures. Investigation on whether functional computed tomography (CT)-scanning is decisive in the investigation of functional outcome after C2 fractures. Pertinent literature exists concerning indications, techniques, complications of treatment, and risk factors for nonunion in C2 fractures; however, there are scarce data regarding the functional outcome in C2 fractures. Only a few studies assess functional outcome in terms of clinical outcome vehicles and clinical investigation of axial neck rotation, using a handheld goniometer. Measurements of axial neck rotation using a handheld goniometer are assumed not sufficient to compare the results of treatment strategies for C2-fractures or elucidate the ability for posttreatment rotation of C1-C2. The authors selected a homogenous group of 35 patients treated for C2 fractures using nonsurgical and surgical techniques. 69% of patients had odontoid fractures. Mean age of patients was 52 years. Patients were subjected to clinical assessment of axial cervical range of motion for rotation, using a handheld goniometer. Patients were also subjected to functional CT-scanning and measurements of total neck and atlantoaxial rotation were performed according to an established protocol. With clinical measurements mean range of motion for left and right axial neck rotation was both 56 degrees. According to the functional CT scans, the mean left-sided and right-sided axial neck rotation was 48.6 degrees and 52.0 degrees. The mean for left- and right-sided atlantoaxial rotation was 20.2 degrees and 20.6 degrees. Total axial atlantoaxial rotation on CT scans was 40.3 degrees and total axial neck rotation was 103.3 degrees. In comparison to age and gender matched normal individuals total cervical neck rotation was reduced to a mean of 69.5%. The differences between total axial neck rotation assessed using a handheld goniometer and with functional CT-scanning were strongly significant (P < 0.0001). In addition, there was no statistically significant correlation between the clinically assessed total neck rotation to either the left or the right side and the ipsilateral percentage atlantoaxial rotation of total head neck rotation. The current study demonstrated that for the comparison of functional outcome after different therapies of C2 fractures clinical measurements do not serve for reliable data on total neck rotation and particularly atlantoaxial rotation and the percentage of C1-C2 rotation of total neck rotation. The use of dynamic CT-scans in the analysis of functional outcome after C2 fractures is strongly recommended.Keywords
This publication has 32 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Contemporary Treatment of Odontoid InjuriesSpine, 2006
- Die instabile traumatische Spondylolisthese C2/3 - Ergebnisse und Empfehlungen nach operativer Stabilisierung in 34 Fällen und LiteraturübersichtAktuelle Traumatologie, 2005
- Results of Long-Term Follow-Up in Patients Undergoing Anterior Screw Fixation for Type II and Rostral Type III Odontoid FracturesSpine, 2005
- Proposal of a modified, treatment-oriented classification of odontoid fracturesThe Spine Journal, 2005
- Zur Problematik der Reosteosynthese bei DenspseudarthroseDer Unfallchirurg, 2004
- Management of Combination Fractures of the Atlas and Axis in AdultsNeurosurgery, 2002
- Evidence-based analysis of odontoid fracture managementNeurosurgical Focus, 2000
- Die direkte Verschraubung von Frakturen des Dens axisDer Unfallchirurg, 2000
- Management of Acute Odontoid Fractures with Single-screw Anterior FixationNeurosurgery, 1999
- Functional Outcome of Surgically and Conservatively Managed Dens FracturesSpine, 1998