Cross-comparing different protocols for DNA metabarcoding of freshwater macroinvertebrates
Open Access
- 5 September 2025
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Hydrobiologia
- Vol. 853 (4) , 1217-1231
Abstract
Macroinvertebrates are widely used in freshwater biomonitoring, but current methods are labor-intensive and require taxonomic expertise. DNA metabarcoding offers a potential solution, though results vary per applied sampling protocol. Here, we compare several protocols using macroinvertebrate samples from a Dutch peatland. Live-sorted specimens were (i) identified morphologically followed by (ii) non-destructive (soft-lysis) and (iii) destructive DNA extraction protocols (aggressive-lysis). Additionally, (iv) unsorted samples (including substrate and plant material) were homogenized, and (v) water-derived eDNA collected. Only 25% of macroinvertebrate taxa were detected across all methods. Aggressive-lysis of live-sorted macroinvertebrates provided a community composition most comparable to the morphology-based identification (mean ± sd = 70 ± 6%), followed by soft-lysis (58 ± 7%). Some beetle taxa were missed using soft-lysis, likely due to insufficient DNA release. Unsorted-debris and eDNA samples showed lower similarity to morphological identifications, with only 31 ± 9% and 20 ± 9% community overlap, respectively. These results suggest aggressive-lysis best replicates traditional assessments, while soft-lysis offers a non-destructive alternative with some taxonomic bias. Unsorted samples and eDNA approaches capture additional diversity but show lower overlap with traditional methods. Our results underscore the importance of protocol selection in DNA-based biomonitoring of freshwater macroinvertebrates.Keywords
Funding Information
- Ministerie van Landbouw, Natuur en Voedselkwaliteit (BO-43-123-003)
This publication has 54 references indexed in Scilit:
- Capture—Incubate—Release: An Animal‐Friendly Approach to Assess Local Aquatic Macroinvertebrate Species Diversity Through Environmental DNA MetabarcodingEnvironmental DNA, 2025
- Environmental DNA metabarcoding on aquatic insects: Comparing the primer sets of MtInsects‐16S based on the mtDNA 16S and general marker based on the mtDNA COI regionEnvironmental DNA, 2024
- River benthic macroinvertebrates and environmental DNA metabarcoding: a scoping review of eDNA sampling, extraction, amplification and sequencing methodsBiodiversity and Conservation, 2023
- Improved freshwater macroinvertebrate detection from environmental DNA through minimized nontarget amplificationEnvironmental DNA, 2020
- Metabarcoding unsorted kick‐samples facilitates macroinvertebrate‐based biomonitoring with increased taxonomic resolution, while outperforming environmental DNAEnvironmental DNA, 2020
- To composite or replicate: how sampling method and protocol differences alter collected stream invertebrates and associated bioassessment metricsEnvironmental Monitoring and Assessment, 2020
- Simultaneous Inference in General Parametric ModelsBiometrical Journal, 2008
- Lattice2008
- Effects of sampling and sub-sampling variation using the STAR-AQEM sampling protocol on the precision of macroinvertebrate metricsHydrobiologia, 2006
- Sampling macrofauna in ditchesAquatic Ecology, 1981