Law and the Regulation of Family Secrets
Author:
- 28 August 2010
- journal article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in International Journal of Law, Policy and The Family
- Vol. 24 (3) , 397-413
Abstract
This article addresses the changing relationship between traditional legal definitions of motherhood and fatherhood and newer scientific definitions of parenthood. It is acknowledged that procedures like DNA testing have transformed legal interpretations, but in so doing it is argued that the social and cultural significance of kinship has been squeezed out of consideration. There is now an almost unassailable presumption that it is best for a child to know his or her genetic origins, yet there is also evidence that families still keep certain matters (eg donor conception) a secret. These families are increasingly defined as out of step with modern, ethical thinking yet it may be important to understand how such families define a child's welfare. The problem with knowledge about genetic links is that it is not mere ‘information’ but is powerful knowledge that changes relationships regardless of the wishes of those involved. The fear of such changes may mean families prefer to reject openness, especially if the risks of loss appear too high. These issues are explored through data on family secrets and also through an unusual legal case involving a child who took the decision not to know his own genetic origins. The article concludes that it is important, in the rush to impose transparency and openness on families, that we are aware of the negative as well as positive consequences.Keywords
This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit:
- Family Secrets: Law and Understandings of Openness in Everyday RelationshipsJournal of Social Policy, 2009
- The experiences of adolescents and adults conceived by sperm donation: comparisons by age of disclosure and family typeHuman Reproduction, 2009
- Donor-Conceived People's Access to Genetic and Biographical History: An Analysis of Provisions in Different Jurisdictions Permitting Disclosure of Donor IdentityInternational Journal of Law, Policy and The Family, 2009
- Gamete donation: parents' experiences of searching for their child's donor siblings and donorHuman Reproduction, 2008
- Embryo donation parents' attitudes towards donors: comparison with adoptionHuman Reproduction, 2008
- Parents Dilemmas in Sharing Donor Insemination Conception Stories with their ChildrenChildren & Society, 2007
- Topic avoidance and family functioning in families conceived with donor inseminationHuman Reproduction, 2007
- Paternity Secrets: Why Women Don’t TellJournal of Family Studies, 2005
- ‘Knowing where you’ve come from’: Ruptures and continuities of time and kinship in narratives of adoption reunionsJournal of the Royal Anthropological Institute, 2000
- ‘SECRECY’: WHAT CAN ARTIFICIAL REPRODUCTION LEARN FROM ADOPTION?International Journal of Law, Policy and The Family, 1988